Before Instagram feeds and celebrity TikToks, teenage crushes arrived at the newsstand. A new issue of 16 Magazine could mean glossy photos, breathless interviews, and a face destined to be carefully torn out and taped to a bedroom wall. In the 1980s, Hollywood produced an absurd number of those faces, sometimes packing several future heartthrobs into the very same movie. Looking back at who actually dominated those magazine covers reveals just how quickly teenage tastes could change.