Hollywood Never Saw This One Coming
For four years, they shared house keys, hidden weekends and movie dates that began after the lights went down. Somehow, two recognizable stars kept nearly all of it away from the cameras and gossip columns.
Barbara Stanwyck never publicly told her side of the story. Robert Wagner waited nearly two decades after she was gone before giving his fullest account.
John Kobal Foundation, Getty Images
It Started On The Titanic
Stanwyck and Wagner met while making Titanic, the 1953 film released more than four decades before Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet boarded a very different version of the doomed ship. Stanwyck played a wealthy mother. Wagner played the young man interested in her daughter.
He Was Still The New Kid
Wagner was 22 and only beginning to establish himself at 20th Century Fox. He had attracted attention in With a Song in My Heart, but he was still learning how movies were made and how a young contract player was expected to behave around a star of Stanwyck’s stature.
unknown (20th Century Fox), Wikimedia Commons
She Was Already Barbara Stanwyck
Stanwyck was 45, had been appearing in movies since 1929 and had already received all four of her competitive Academy Award nominations. She was not merely the more experienced actor. She was one of the most respected and powerful women Hollywood had ever produced.
Whitey Schafer, Wikimedia Commons
Her Marriage Had Recently Ended
Stanwyck’s divorce from actor Robert Taylor had been finalized in 1951 after more than a decade of marriage. By the time she met Wagner, she was single again—but still one of the most recognizable women in Hollywood.
Gordon Charles Wallace, Los Angeles Times, Wikimedia Commons
At First, She Was Simply Helping Him
Stanwyck had a history of looking out for younger performers. She had famously supported William Holden when the studio considered removing him from Golden Boy, and Wagner later said she changed his approach to acting and made him want to learn the business completely.
Donaldson Collection, Getty Images
Then Came The Party
A few weeks into filming, director Jean Negulesco held a Saturday-night party. Wagner accompanied Stanwyck and remained close to her throughout the evening, although he still could not tell whether she regarded him as an attractive man or merely another young actor she had decided to help.
Everything Changed At Her Front Door
Wagner drove Stanwyck home and opened her door. When he looked up, he later wrote, something in her expression had changed. He kissed her, she responded, and the two went inside. According to Wagner, they opened champagne, danced together and remained awake until dawn.
This Was Not A One-Night Hollywood Story
Things reportedly became serious almost immediately. Stanwyck gave Wagner a key to her house, and he gave her one to his apartment. When their schedules allowed it, they spent entire weekends together rather than squeezing in the occasional hidden dinner between movie shoots.
ABC Television, Wikimedia Commons
Their Dates Were Designed To Disappear
They watched Friday-night boxing matches, cooked at home and walked in the mountains above Malibu. When they went to a theater, they arrived after the lights had gone down. Stanwyck sometimes covered her recognizable face with a scarf or hat to avoid being spotted.
Even The Rumors Helped Hide Them
There had been whispers while Titanic was being made, but Wagner publicly dismissed them as nonsense. He complained that the gossip threatened his friendship with a great actress. Looking back, the denial reads like an extremely effective piece of old-Hollywood misdirection.
20th Century Fox, Getty Images
Hollywood Was Built For Secrets
This was an era when studios, publicists and friendly columnists could keep inconvenient relationships away from moviegoers. Wagner later said the situation had been “handled,” that the couple remained extremely discreet and that other people occasionally helped disguise what was happening.
John Kobal Foundation / Contributor, Getty Images
A Few People Apparently Knew
According to accounts surrounding Wagner’s memoir, the relationship was known to a small circle that included Nancy Sinatra Sr.—Frank Sinatra’s first wife—and Spencer Tracy. Tracy certainly understood Hollywood secrecy. His own long relationship with Katharine Hepburn remained carefully guarded for years.
The Age Difference Could Not Be Ignored
There were 23 years between them, and Wagner later said neither wanted the relationship in the papers because of that difference. The secrecy was deliberate, assisted by Stanwyck’s publicist and a small circle of friends who knew what was happening.
McFadden, Strauss, Eddy & Irwin, Wikimedia Commons
He Insisted He Was Not Her Little Diversion
When Wagner first publicly discussed the relationship in 2002, he rejected the suggestion that he had merely been a young man temporarily entertaining an older actress. “I was her love,” he said. To Wagner, this had been a defining relationship, not an amusing Hollywood adventure.
CBS Television, Wikimedia Commons
She Gave Him Something Fame Had Not
Wagner was handsome, increasingly popular and receiving plenty of attention, but he later credited Stanwyck with providing something deeper. “She gave me self-esteem,” he wrote. Knowing that a woman of her experience and accomplishments believed in him changed how the young actor saw himself.
Whitey Schafer, Wikimedia Commons
His Career Was Suddenly Taking Off
During 1953, Wagner’s profile exploded. He later recalled appearing on seven magazine covers in a single month while Fox claimed he was receiving more fan mail than Marilyn Monroe. Yet the woman occupying most of his private life remained completely absent from those breathless fan-magazine stories.
Twentieth Century-Fox, Wikimedia Commons
Her Career Was Not Exactly Slowing Down
Stanwyck was simultaneously making films including All I Desire, Titanic and a string of westerns. She would later move successfully into television, star in The Big Valley and win three Emmy Awards. Finding time together was difficult because neither person was willing—or able—to stop working.
Screenshot from Titanic, 20th Century-Fox (1953)
Four Years Still Was Not Forever
The relationship eventually ended. In Wagner’s telling, their schedules, the age difference and the realities of their separate careers made a lasting future increasingly difficult. Stanwyck was reportedly the one who finally ended it.
ABC Television, Wikimedia Commons
He Knew Exactly What People Would Call Him
“I would always have been Mr. Stanwyck,” Wagner later wrote, “and we both knew it.” It was a funny line, but it exposed the problem. She had already built a legendary career. He was only beginning to discover whether he could build one of his own.
Then Natalie Wood Entered His Life
Wagner began dating Natalie Wood in 1956, near the end of the four-year period he assigned to his relationship with Stanwyck. Wagner and Wood married in December 1957, beginning one of Hollywood’s most famous—and eventually most tragic—love stories.
They Never Really Left Each Other’s Lives
Although the romance ended, Wagner said he and Stanwyck remained close for the rest of her life. Whatever disappointment came with their breakup apparently did not erase the affection, influence or friendship created during those hidden weekends in the 1950s.
Ron Galella, Ltd., Getty Images
Stanwyck Never Told Her Side
There is one important limitation to the story: almost every intimate detail comes from Wagner. Stanwyck never publicly confirmed the relationship, and she was no longer alive when his fullest account appeared. Readers are hearing his memories of the affair—not a jointly documented version of events.
Silver Screen Collection, Getty Images
The First Admission Actually Came Earlier
Wagner first publicly acknowledged the romance in a 2002 interview, roughly 12 years after Stanwyck’s 1990 passing. At that time, he described it as lasting five years. His 2008 memoir placed it at four, which became the duration repeated in most later accounts.
Unknown photographer, Wikimedia Commons
The Full Story Arrived Nearly 20 Years Later
Wagner published Pieces of My Heart in 2008, more than 18 years after Stanwyck was gone. The memoir finally included the party, the kiss, the exchanged keys, the disguised movie dates and the private domestic life almost nobody had known existed.
He Could Barely Read The Chapter
Before publication, Wagner tried reading the Stanwyck chapter aloud to his wife, Jill St. John, and a friend. He became so emotional that he could not finish. Nearly five decades after the relationship ended, writing about it had apparently reopened something he had never completely put away.
Albert L. Ortega, Getty Images
She Had Remained A Piece Of His Heart
“She was such a big part of my life,” Wagner said while promoting the book. By then, Stanwyck had been gone for nearly 19 years, the studio system that once protected them had vanished and their relationship no longer threatened either career. But it clearly still mattered to him.
Hollywood Kept The Secret. Wagner Kept The Memory.
Barbara Stanwyck never publicly discussed the young actor who once carried keys to her home. Robert Wagner eventually told enough for the world to understand that this had not been a brief fling. For four years, one of Hollywood’s biggest stars had lived an entirely different life after the cameras stopped.
You Might Also Like:
Suave Facts About Humphrey Bogart, Hollywood's Hardboiled Hero
How Nancy Kulp Became One Of The Sharpest Scene-Stealers On 1960s Television
![Smith [1], Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Robert_Wagner_by_Smith,_1954.jpg){kind=link}
