While David Letterman was making millions laugh on late-night television in the 80s, a complete stranger became convinced she was his wife.

Discover the disturbing true story of David Letterman and Margaret Mary Ray, a woman who believed she was his wife, entered his home repeatedly, and stole his prized Porsche.

David Letterman [CBS talk show host, New York]. Creator: Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer. Date Created/Published: 1982. Medium: 1 photograph: color transparency; 35mm (slide format). Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-gtfy-02267

A Late-Night Star's Real-Life Nightmare

David Letterman made millions laugh on late-night television, but behind the scenes, he faced a situation that was anything but funny. Margaret Mary Ray became convinced she was his wife, repeatedly entering his Connecticut home and even driving away in his Porsche. For years, Letterman endured unwanted visits, arrests, and bizarre encounters. 

So why did he eventually try to help the woman who refused to leave him alone?

David Letterman [CBS talk show host, New York]. Creator: Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer. Date Created/Published: 1982. Medium: 1 photograph: color transparency; 35mm (slide format). Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-gtfy-02267 Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The King Of Late-Night Comedy

By the late 1980s, David Letterman was one of television's most recognizable comedians. His NBC show, Late Night with David Letterman, had earned a devoted audience with its sarcastic humor and unconventional interviews. Away from the cameras, however, he was facing a situation that was anything but funny. A stranger had become convinced she belonged in his life.

Title: Teri Garr, actress, with David Letterman
Creator(s): Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer
Date Created/Published: 1982.
Medium: 1 photograph : color transparency ; 35mm (slide format)
Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-gtfy-02278 (digital file from original)
RiGotfryd, Bernard, photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

A Stranger Became Obsessed

Her name was Margaret Mary Ray, a 36-year-old woman from Colorado. According to a later ABC News report, her obsession began after she attended a taping of his NBC program. Although she was a stranger to Letterman, Ray became convinced she belonged in his personal life.  

Title: David Letterman [CBS talkshow host, New York]
Creator(s): Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer
Date Created/Published: 1982.
Medium: 1 photograph : color transparency ; 35mm (slide format)
Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-gtfy-02272 (digital file from originaGotfryd, Bernard, photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Believed She Was His Wife

Ray's conviction went far beyond an ordinary celebrity crush. She claimed to be Letterman's wife and even referred to her three-year-old son as David Jr. Letterman, who was unmarried at the time, had no such relationship with her. Her extraordinary claims became national news following an incident in May 1988.

Screenshot from Absolute Crime (2022-)Screenshot from Absolute Crime, Little Dot Studios (2022-), Enhanced

Advertisement

She Took His Porsche

On May 22, 1988, Ray broke into Letterman's Connecticut home and took his midnight-blue Porsche Carrera. The comedian was away in California at the time, unaware that a stranger had entered his property. Ray brought her three-year-old son along for the ride. Their journey toward Manhattan ended because of a remarkably small amount of money.

Late night television talk show personality David Letterman hosting the David Letterman Show from the Chicago Theater in Chicago Illinois,Paul Natkin, Getty Images

Advertisement

A Three-Dollar Toll Exposed Everything

When Ray reached the Lincoln Tunnel, she couldn't pay the $3 toll. She told the toll collector she was Mrs. David Letterman and introduced her son as David Jr. The explanation raised suspicions, and authorities checked the Porsche's registration. They discovered that the vehicle really did belong to the famous television host.

Inside the Lincoln Tunnel.deltaMike, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Letterman Got An Unexpected Call

Authorities contacted Letterman, who confirmed that Ray was not his wife and had no permission to drive his car. He reported the Porsche stolen, and she was charged with receiving stolen property. Her bail was set at $5,000, with a $500 cash option. But police soon discovered something even more troubling about his Connecticut property.

American talk show host David Letterman stands with one leg over a railing at his home, Westchester County, New York, March 1984Susan Wood/Getty Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

Someone Had Been Living In His House

Officers investigating the incident visited Letterman's three-bedroom home in New Canaan. They found signs that someone had apparently been staying there for several days, including moved plants and a rug. Although police initially stopped short of identifying Ray as the intruder, later accounts linked her to the unauthorized stay. Letterman declined to pursue charges over that first intrusion.

American talk show host David Letterman kicks off his shoes while sitting on his bed, Westchester County, New York, March 1984.Susan Wood/Getty Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

She Returned Days Later

Ray's initial arrest did little to discourage her. On May 26, 1988, police found her inside Letterman's house again after a taxi driver alerted them. She had reportedly been eating food from his kitchen and cutting pictures from magazines. This time, authorities pursued burglary and larceny charges.

Screenshot from Celebs Up Close (2024-)Screenshot from Celebs Up Close, ITV Studios (2024-), Enhanced

Advertisement

She Wanted To Clean His House

During the second intrusion, Ray reportedly insisted that she was Letterman's housekeeper. She even wanted to tidy up before officers took her away. According to police, she believed the comedian would expect to return to a clean home. In reality, Letterman had never employed her.

Host David Letterman poses for a portrait in circa1983 in Los Angeles, California.Donaldson Collection, Getty Images

Advertisement

A Judge Ordered Psychiatric Treatment

Ray's repeated intrusions soon raised serious concerns about her mental health. In June 1988, a Connecticut judge ordered further psychiatric evaluation after a doctor described her thinking as delusional. She subsequently received treatment at Fairfield Hills, a state psychiatric hospital. Authorities also imposed restrictions intended to keep her away from Letterman.

The hospitalG F, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Returned Despite The Restrictions

In February 1989, Ray was arrested after authorities discovered she had entered Letterman's home again. She faced additional trespassing charges despite an earlier court order restricting contact with the comedian. The order had allowed communication only through the mail. Yet Ray continued appearing at his property in person.

Screenshot from Absolute Crime (2022-)Screenshot from Absolute Crime, Little Dot Studios (2022-), Enhanced

Advertisement

She Was Found Near His Tennis Courts

In August 1989, Ray was spotted wandering around the tennis courts at Letterman's estate. Her appearance violated the conditions of her probation, although Letterman initially wanted police to issue only a warning. Court officials subsequently ordered her arrest. This time, her repeated visits resulted in a prison sentence.

Late night television talk show personality David Letterman hosting the David Letterman Show from the Chicago Theater in Chicago Illinois, May 1, 1989.Paul Natkin, Getty Images

Advertisement

She Was Sent To Prison

Ray received three concurrent nine-month prison sentences for violating her probation. She was incarcerated at Connecticut's Niantic prison for women, serving approximately seven months before her release in March 1990. Authorities hoped the punishment would discourage further intrusions. Instead, she returned to Letterman's property almost immediately.

Screenshot from Celebs Up Close (2024-)Screenshot from Celebs Up Close, ITV Studios (2024-), Enhanced

Advertisement

He Found Her Asleep In His Bedroom

In March 1990, Letterman returned from a California vacation and discovered a broken window at his house. Police subsequently found Ray asleep in an upstairs bedroom. She had been released from prison just two days earlier. Letterman declined to press charges over that particular intrusion, but the situation took another alarming turn.

File:David Letterman with Amy Carter.jpgBernard Gotfryd, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

A Shadow Appeared In The Hallway

Less than 24 hours later, Letterman and his girlfriend were in bed when he thought he smelled smoke from the fireplace. As he sat up to investigate, his girlfriend spotted someone standing at the end of the hallway. It was Ray, just 30 feet away. Letterman called the police, and Ray fled before officers caught her near the tennis courts.

American talk show host David Letterman sits for a portrait while on his bed at his home, Westchester County, New York, March 1984.Susan Wood/Getty Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

Letterman Testified In Court

On April 30, 1990, Letterman appeared in Norwalk Superior Court to testify about Ray's repeated visits. He described finding her asleep inside his house and encountering her in the hallway the following night. By then, she had appeared uninvited at his property more than half a dozen times. His testimony revealed how persistent and unsettling the intrusions had become.

Title: David Letterman [CBS talkshow host, New York]
Creator(s): Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer
Date Created/Published: 1982.
Medium: 1 photograph : color transparency ; 35mm (slide format)
Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-gtfy-02265 (digital file from originaGotfryd, Bernard, photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Disappeared From A Hospital

In March 1991, Ray disappeared from Fairfield Hills Hospital, where she had been receiving psychiatric treatment. Hospital staff discovered she was missing and notified authorities. However, state police said her disappearance was not being treated as an escape. She had left behind a note explaining where she intended to go.

Photograph taken in November 2017 of the main building at the abandoned Fairfield Hills Mental Hospital in Newtown, Connecticut.Marty Aligata, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Promised To Leave Him Alone

In the note, Ray said she was returning to Colorado and would no longer bother Letterman. After years of unwanted visits and arrests, the promise suggested her fixation might finally be ending. The comedian had already spent considerable time dealing with intrusions into his private life. Unfortunately, Ray did not keep her word.

American talk show host David Letterman pets his dog near his home, Westchester County, New York, March 1984.Susan Wood/Getty Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

She Turned Up Again In 1992

In March 1992, Ray returned to Letterman's estate in New Canaan. A taxi driver alerted police, who intercepted her as she arrived at the property. Rather than arresting her, officers put her on a commuter train to New York City. Authorities offered no immediate explanation for their decision, despite Ray's earlier promise to leave Letterman alone.

Screenshot from Celebs Up Close (2024-)Screenshot from Celebs Up Close, ITV Studios (2024-), Enhanced

Advertisement

She Left Strange Gifts Behind

Ray's visits sometimes involved more than simply entering Letterman's property. She reportedly left cookies and an empty whiskey bottle in his foyer, along with letters and a book about meditation in his driveway. On other occasions, she behaved as though she had responsibilities around the house. Her actions reflected the imagined relationship she continued to believe existed.

American talk show host David Letterman poses while leaning on a television set as his home, Westchester County, New York, March 1984Susan Wood/Getty Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

Even Security Couldn't Keep Her Away

Letterman eventually installed a security system, but he later complained that it created problems of its own. Harmless activity could trigger alarms, while Ray still managed to reach his property. He recalled one incident in which she camped near his tennis court despite the precautions. At one point, she even used his swimming pool to do her laundry.

David Letterman hosting United States President Barack Obama on the Late Show with David Letterman on 21 September 2009. Letterman is showing a photograph of the President and his wife wearing 3-D glasses while watching the Super Bowl in the family theatePete Souza, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Wrote Him Constantly

Ray's fixation also extended to letters. In an interview published in the January 1994 issue of Playboy, Letterman said she had been writing to him for approximately six years. Sometimes three or four letters arrived in a single day. He observed that her writing was more coherent when she was receiving medication.

David Letterman on The Blocks Podcast with Neal BrennanNeal Brennan, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Turned It Into A Joke

As the story became public, Letterman occasionally used the situation as material for his comedy. During his final NBC show in June 1993, he included a reference to Ray in a Top Ten list about leaving the network. One item involved sending a change-of-address form to the woman who kept entering his house. But he later acknowledged that the joke troubled him.

Screenshot from Late Night with David Letterman (1982–1993)Screenshot from Late Night with David Letterman, NBC (1982–1993), Enhanced

Advertisement

He Regretted Making Light Of It

In his Playboy interview, Letterman admitted he had sometimes handled the situation poorly. He did not consider Ray a genuine threat, despite the repeated intrusions. Instead, he believed she was a woman experiencing serious psychiatric difficulties who had not received adequate help. His concern eventually led him to consider doing something personally.

david letterman photographed by zach catanzaretiZach Catanzareti Photo, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Tried To Help Her

Letterman revealed that he had spoken with his attorney about finding a way to help Ray. He believed the judicial and psychiatric systems had failed to provide the assistance she needed. Although their efforts ultimately fell apart, he remained sympathetic toward her circumstances. Meanwhile, Ray's attention was shifting toward another famous man.

Team owner and Indiana native David Letterman on pit road prior to the NTT IndyCar Series 103rd running of the Indianapolis 500 on May 26, 2019, in Indianapolis, IN.Icon Sportswire, Getty Images

Advertisement

Another Celebrity Caught Her Attention

Ray subsequently developed a fixation on Story Musgrave, a NASA astronaut who had helped repair the Hubble Space Telescope. According to investigators, she contacted him repeatedly over approximately four years. Her efforts included telephone calls, letters, and packages sent to his home. She also reportedly arranged an interview with him by pretending to be a journalist.

Story Musgrave (M.D.), NASA AstronautNASA, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Appeared At The Astronaut's Home

In September 1997, authorities found Ray outside Musgrave's home in Kissimmee, Florida. According to sheriff's reports, she had banged on the front door early in the morning and turned on outdoor water faucets. She was arrested and charged with stalking. From jail, she declared that she loved Musgrave and wanted to spend her life with him.

The original finding aid described this as: Description: STS-80 Mission Specialist Story Musgrave notes the time and temperature on the Cell Culture Module A (CCM-A) middeck locker experiment. Subject Terms: STS-80,COLUMBIA (ORBITER),ASTRONAUTS,MIDDECK,SPNational Aeronautics and Space Administration. Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center. 2/17/1973, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Her Legal Troubles Continued

In June 1998, Ray pleaded guilty to stalking Musgrave. Two months later, she also pleaded guilty to misdemeanor assault involving a corrections officer. She received a 246-day jail sentence but was released with credit for time served. Her years of psychiatric treatment, arrests, and imprisonment had not resolved her difficulties.

Story Musgrave (on the right) gets assistance from Thomas D. Akers while suiting up for the final space walk on the eleven-day, Hubble Space Telescope (HST) first servicing mission in December 1993. Musgrave joined astronaut Jeffrey A. Hoffman on three spNASA Hubble Space Telescope, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Letterman's Final Words

On October 5, 1998, Margaret Mary Ray took her own life near Hotchkiss, Colorado, at the age of 46. Her death came more than a decade after she first became convinced she was David Letterman's wife. Despite years of unwanted visits, the comedian responded with sympathy rather than anger. He described her death as "a sad end to a confused life."

Comedian David Letterman speaks onstage at the 32nd Annual Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony at Barclays Center on April 7, 2017 in New York City.Jeff Kravitz, Getty Images

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

The Original SNL Cast: 7 Comedy Legends Who Changed Television Forever

Gene Wilder and Richard Pryor Had Perfect On-Screen Chemistry—And Plenty of Off-Screen Tension

Late Night TV Guest Hosts Through The Decades—Did You Catch Any Of Their Episodes?

Sources:  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13


✕