Oscar-Worthy Performances That Went Unrewarded

Oscar-Worthy Performances That Went Unrewarded


June 12, 2025 | Marlon Wright

Oscar-Worthy Performances That Went Unrewarded


Harsh Realities Of Hollywood

Spotlight or not, some performances never fade. These actors changed the atmosphere in every room their characters entered. And still…no win.

Oscar-Worthy Performances Went Unrewarded

Advertisement

Orson Welles, Citizen Kane

Shatter expectations? Welles did just that at 25, directing and starring in Citizen Kane, the film that reinvented cinema. Playing Charles Foster Kane, he delivered raw charisma, complex rage, and tragic ambition. Yet the Academy gave him zilch for acting. Talk about rewriting the rules…and still getting snubbed.

File:Citizen-Kane-Comingore-Welles-Collins.jpgRKO Radio Pictures, still photographer Alexander Kahle, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Cary Grant, Penny Serenade

Drama wasn’t Grant’s default, but in Penny Serenade, he shifted gears. As a husband reliving life through vinyl records, he served heartbreak with polish and power.

Advertisement

You felt every crack in his composure. The nomination? Earned. The win? Stolen. How does Hollywood miss a breakdown that’s so fully built?

File:Cary Grant in Penny Serenade (1941).pngColumbia Pictures (Life time: 1970), Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Marlon Brando, A Streetcar Named Desire

Intensity like Brando’s doesn’t whisper—it roars. His Stanley Kowalski role stomped, sweated, and shattered the idea of subtle masculinity. His shout—“STELLA”—still echoes through pop culture. He was nominated but not victorious. The role launched a new acting era but left Brando empty-handed that night.

Advertisement

File:Marlon Brando in 'Streetcar named Desire' trailer (cropped).jpgTrailer screenshot, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Richard Burton, Who’s Afraid Of Virginia Woolf?

Volatility met vulnerability in Burton’s George, a man drowning in academic bitterness and booze. In Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, his sparring with Elizabeth Taylor was fire and glass. Four nominations deep at the time, Burton brought the house down…but the Academy left the door closed.

Richard Burton, Who’s Afraid Of Virginia WoolfElizabeth Taylor - What A Dump by Lado Gachechiladze

Advertisement

Peter O’Toole, Lawrence Of Arabia

Desert winds swept O’Toole into cinematic legend, but the Oscar breeze passed right by. As Lawrence in Lawrence of Arabia, he became a myth. That haunting stare was unforgettable, and that seven-nomination streak without a win?

Advertisement

Absolutely baffling. You can’t call that fair, can you?

File:Peter O'Toole in Lawrence of Arabia.pngColumbia Pictures, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Audrey Hepburn, My Fair Lady

and ball gown. Though My Fair Lady dazzled with wins, she didn’t even get a nod. Hollywood’s excuse was that she didn’t sing. This was odd, considering her performance spoke volumes.

File:My Fair Lady Audrey Hepburn.jpgCecil Beaton., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Robert De Niro, Taxi Driver

“Are you talkin’ to me”? Yeah, everyone still is. De Niro’s Travis Bickle in the movie was a powder keg of loneliness and delusion. The mohawk.

Advertisement

The mirror scene. That slow-burn descent into madness? Chilling. He drove the whole film, and yet someone else walked off with the golden statue.

Robert De Niro, Taxi DriverTaxi Driver (5/8) Movie CLIP - You Talkin' to Me? (1976) HD by Movieclips

Advertisement

Sigourney Weaver, Aliens

Bravery isn’t always brawny. Weaver’s Ripley in Aliens proved that grit and grace can coexist. She traversed flamethrowers and grief while protecting Newt like a battle-hardened mother lion. Her Oscar loss was an industry oversight. Because let’s be honest: who else could command a power loader with that much soul?

Advertisement

Sigourney Weaver, AliensALIENS CLIP COMPILATION (1986) Sci-Fi, Sigourney Weaver by JoBlo Movie Clips

Advertisement

Glenn Close, Fatal Attraction

Ever boiled a rabbit? Glenn Close made it unforgettable. Her portrayal of Alex Forrest in Fatal Attraction turned the psychological thriller into a pop-culture legend. Vulnerable yet unhinged, seductive yet scorned, she was terrified and mesmerized in equal measure. Still, the Academy passed.

Glenn Close, Fatal AttractionFatal Attraction (6/8) Movie CLIP - Not Going to Be Ignored (1987) HD by Movieclips

Advertisement

Tom Cruise, Born On The Fourth Of July

Cruise stripped away every bit of movie-star polish to play Vietnam vet Ron Kovic in Born on the Fourth of July. Wheelchair-bound, shattered, and unflinchingly real, he showed a side rarely seen.

Advertisement

The transformation was staggering. The message? Loud. The Oscar? Out of reach. Timing, it seems, is brutal.

Tom Cruise, Born On The Fourth Of JulyBorn on the Fourth of July | "I Love America" by Universal Pictures

Advertisement

Angela Bassett, What’s Love Got To Do With It

Tina Turner’s fire needed a furnace, and Angela Bassett delivered it. In What’s Love Got to Do with It, she didn’t mimic Tina; she lived her rebirth and rhythm. Her voice cracked with truth. Her body bore bruises and brilliance. The Oscar went elsewhere. But who remembers the winner?

Advertisement

Angela Bassett, What’s Love Got To Do With ItAngela Bassett as Tina Turner (1993)What's Love Got To Do With It by WE LOVE MUSIC AND MOVIES

Advertisement

Leonardo DiCaprio, What’s Eating Gilbert Grape

At just 19, DiCaprio blurred the line between actor and character. As Arnie in What’s Eating Gilbert Grape, he captured a developmental disorder with realism so startling that some thought it wasn’t performance. But it was. And it was genius. His first nomination should’ve been his first Oscar win. No dice.

Leonardo Dicaprio, What’s Eating Gilbert GrapeWhat's Eating Gilbert Grape/Best scene/Leonardo DiCaprio/Johnny Depp/Darlene Cates/Laura Harrington by Eli

Advertisement

Ed Norton, Primal Fear

Rookies rarely rattle the Oscars, but Norton came close. In Primal Fear, he played a stuttering altar boy with chilling duality. The courtroom twist was legendary.

Advertisement

Audiences leaned in, and the critics stood up.

Advertisement

Norton walked away with a nomination but no statue. Why?

Ed Norton, Primal Fear Advertisement

Audiences leaned in, and the critics stood up". data-title="Rookies rarely rattle the Oscars, but Norton came close. In Primal Fear, he played a stuttering altar boy with chilling duality. The courtroom twist was legendary.

Advertisement

Audiences leaned in, and the critics stood up". class="fr-fic fr-dib" alt="Ed Norton, Primal Fear">Primal Fear (5/9) Movie CLIP - Meeting "Roy" (1996) HD by Movieclips

Advertisement

Jim Carrey, The Truman Show

When the comedy mask slipped, Carrey shocked everyone. In The Truman Show, he played Truman Burbank, a man trapped in a life-scripted lie. You watched joy turn to paranoia, innocence to existential dread. No nomination, though. Hollywood laughed for years, then went silent when it mattered.

Jim Carrey, The Truman ShowGood Afternoon, Good Evening and Good Night - The Truman Show (1/9) Movie CLIP (1998) HD by Movieclips

Advertisement

Christian Bale, American Psycho

Blood never looked this charismatic. Bale’s Patrick Bateman in American Psycho flexed, smiled, and then killed Huey Lewis. Satirical and savage, he gave capitalism a face and a chainsaw.

Advertisement

The Academy flinched. But cinephiles? They keep replaying the “Hip to Be Square” monolog like it’s gospel.

Christian Bale, American PsychoThe Beginning & End of American Psycho (2000) | Christian Bale by The Dollar Theater

Advertisement

Ellen Burstyn, Requiem For A Dream

Pills and promises unraveled Ellen Burstyn’s character, Sara Goldfarb, with hallucinatory horror. In Requiem for a Dream, she spiraled into addiction, obsessing over TV stardom. Her fridge pulsed. Her eyes hollowed. Her monolog? Devastating. The nomination came. The award didn’t. Yet her performance carved itself into cinema’s darkest corridors.

Ellen Burstyn, Requiem For A Dream'Sara's Disturbing Hallucinations' Scene | Requiem for a Dream by The Dollar Theater

Advertisement

Tom Hanks, Cast Away

Chuck Noland didn’t just lose a plane; he lost four years, a tooth, and Wilson. In Cast Away, Tom Hanks held your attention with coconuts and that haunting raft farewell. Unfortunately, Oscar voters let him drift.

Advertisement

You can still hear “WILSON”! echo, can’t you?

Tom Hanks, Cast AwayCAST AWAY Clip - "Help" (2000) Tom Hanks by JoBlo Movie Clips

Advertisement

Johnny Depp, Pirates Of The Caribbean: The Curse Of The Black Pearl

Rum-soaked and eyeliner-smudged, Depp’s Jack Sparrow swaggered into Pirates like a rock star from the 1700s. He improvised and redefined Disney’s approach to heroes. Critics scoffed, and Depp landed a nomination. But no Oscar. Still, he continued to rake in box office gold for years after.

File:Dale Clark poses as Johnny Depp, in Pirates of the Caribbean, 24391.jpgCarol M. Highsmith, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Christian Bale, The Machinist

Imagine dropping over 60 pounds just to feel invisible. Bale did that for The Machinist when he played Trevor Reznik, a guilt-wracked insomniac unraveling in slow motion. Bones jutted.

Advertisement

Skin paled. Reality fractured. Yet the Academy blinked. Bale sacrificed body and sanity. All he got was cult legend status.

Tom Hanks, Cast AwayThe Machinist trailer by SempriniUK

Advertisement

Amy Adams, Junebug

Amy Adams didn’t whisper onto the screen; she beamed. In Junebug, she played Ashley, a Southern optimist whose joy masked heartbreak. Her monolog about angels was pure, teary magic. The film’s small scale didn’t stop her from towering. An Oscar nod came. But gold?

Advertisement

Not this time, sweetheart.

Amy Adams, JunebugJunebug Trailer Starring Amy Adams by Majid Andary

Advertisement

Jake Gyllenhaal, Brokeback Mountain

Heath Ledger got the spotlight, but Gyllenhaal’s Jack Twist broke you quietly. In Brokeback Mountain, his longing lingered long after the credits. “I wish I knew how to quit you”—not just a line, a seismic emotional collapse. Oscar voters looked away, but Jack’s heartbreak stayed with everyone.

Jake Gyllenhaal, Brokeback MountainBrokeback Mountain | Jake Gyllenhaal and Heath Ledger Get Acquainted | Extended Preview by Universal Pictures All-Access

Advertisement

Leonardo DiCaprio, The Departed

Grit never looked this polished. DiCaprio brought torment and tension to Billy Costigan in The Departed, balancing undercover stress with bursts of fury. Blood, loyalty, and fear pulsed through every scene he touched.

Advertisement

No nomination. Wild, right? Especially when he powered the very film that took Best Picture.

Leonardo Dicaprio, The Departed (1)Best Of The Departed | Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, Jack Nicholson | Amazon Prime Video by Prime Video India

Advertisement

Ryan Gosling, Half Nelson

Addiction stories often fall flat. Not this one. Gosling’s performance as a crack-addicted teacher in Half Nelson peeled back the facade of savior narratives. No lectures, just raw connections. The most heartbreaking scene was undoubtedly the bathroom scene. On the not-so-disappointing side, he snagged a nomination.

Ryan Gosling, Half NelsonHalf Nelson (2006) Trailer | Ryan Gosling | Anthony Mackie by Film Trailer Channel

Advertisement

James McAvoy, Atonement

Words mattered in Atonement, but McAvoy’s silence spoke louder. As Robbie Turner, wronged by lies and class, he gave pain a handsome face.

Advertisement

His final beach scene still haunts me. Audiences wept, and critics raved, yet Oscar voters sat still. McAvoy deserved more than a guilt-soaked love letter.

James Mcavoy, AtonementAtonement | James McAvoy Recalls His Time With Keira Knightley by Focus Features

Advertisement

Michael Fassbender, Hunger

You don’t watch Fassbender’s Bobby Sands; you endure him. In Hunger, he transforms from man to martyr with unwavering intensity. The prison hunger strike, the monolog, that skeletal frame, it’s a commitment most won’t touch. But the Academy starved this film of a nod entirely.

Advertisement

Astonishing, isn’t it?

Michael Fassbender, HungerHunger / Official Trailer (2008) HD by AMBI Distribution

Advertisement

Jamie Foxx, Django Unchained

With bullets and bravado, Foxx lit up Tarantino’s revenge tale. As Django, he fused righteous fury with sharp wit, evolving from slave to gunslinger with panache. His presence anchored Django Unchained, yet no nomination came his way. Funny how the hero of the film wasn’t rewarded as one.

Jamie Foxx, Django UnchainedDjango Unchained Trailer 2 Jamie Foxx & DiCaprio 2012 Movie - Official HD by Stream Movie Trailers

Advertisement

Amy Adams, Arrival

Time bent, but Amy’s performance never cracked. In Arrival, she played linguist Louise Banks, decoding alien language while mourning a daughter. Her restraint carried cosmic weight.

Advertisement

Critics praised her emotional gravity, but the nomination never landed. This is easily one of the decade’s biggest snubs.

Amy Adams, ArrivalArrival Trailer (2016) - Paramount Pictures by Paramount Pictures

Advertisement

Jake Gyllenhaal, Nightcrawler

Creepy never looked so enthralling. As Lou Bloom in Nightcrawler, Gyllenhaal turned wide-eyed ambition into icy sociopathy. He transformed LA’s night into a hunting ground; every smile edged with menace. The performance hit hard. Yet voters ghosted him. You think they just couldn’t look Lou in the eye?

Jake Gyllenhaal, NightcrawlerNightcrawler TRAILER 1 (2014) - Jake Gyllenhaal Crime Drama HD by Rotten Tomatoes Coming Soon

Advertisement

Willem Dafoe, The Florida Project

Motel manager Bobby Hicks wasn’t flashy. But Dafoe made him unforgettable.

Advertisement

In 

The Florida Project, he played protector, disciplinarian, and surrogate father—sometimes all in one scene. Was he the heartbeat of the film?
Advertisement

Absolutely. For this reason, the nomination was earned, but the win? That was denied.

Willem Dafoe, The Florida Project Advertisement

In The Florida Project, he played protector, disciplinarian, and surrogate father—sometimes all in one scene. " data-title="Motel manager Bobby Hicks wasn’t flashy. But Dafoe made him unforgettable.

Advertisement

In The Florida Project, he played protector, disciplinarian, and surrogate father—sometimes all in one scene. " class="fr-fic fr-dib" alt="Willem Dafoe, The Florida Project">The Florida Project | Official Trailer HD | A24 by A24

Advertisement

Florence Pugh, Little Women

Amy March finally got her due, and it was Florence Pugh who delivered it. In Little Women, she revived a character often dismissed as spoiled into something fierce and self-aware. Audiences finally rooted for Amy. The Oscar was just out of reach. Not the justice Amy—or Florence—deserved.

Florence Pugh, Little WomenLittle Women | Marriage is an Economic Proposition (Florence Pugh, Timothée Chalamet) by Moving Pictures

Advertisement

Lupita Nyong’o, Us

Duality never looked more terrifying.

Advertisement

Nyong’o played both mother Adelaide and shadowy doppelganger Red in 

Us, commanding two personas with unnerving precision. Her raspy monolog chilled spines.
Advertisement

Her physicality? Flawless. Yet, not a single nod came her way. How did Hollywood miss a performance this surgically split?

Lupita Nyong’o, Us Advertisement

Nyong’o played both mother Adelaide and shadowy doppelganger Red in Us, commanding two personas with unnerving precision. " data-title="Duality never looked more terrifying.

Advertisement

Nyong’o played both mother Adelaide and shadowy doppelganger Red in Us, commanding two personas with unnerving precision. " class="fr-fic fr-dib" alt="Lupita Nyong’o, Us">Us Movie Clip - Extended Preview (2019) | FandangoNOW Extras by Fandango at Home

Advertisement

Adam Sandler, Uncut Gems

Sandler dropped the goof and gave us desperation incarnate. As jeweler Howard Ratner in Uncut Gems, he spiraled through chaos and addiction. You felt his pulse pounding through every scene. Critics screamed “career-best”. But the Academy was silent. That final shot deserved more than gasps.

Adam Sandler, Uncut GemsUncut Gems: Watch the First 9 Minutes and 59 Seconds | Netflix by Still Watching Netflix

Advertisement

Delroy Lindo, Da 5 Bloods

In this movie, Lindo bared his soul.

Advertisement

As Paul, a traumatized vet in 

Da 5 Bloods, he tore through grief, guilt, fury, and everything in between like a man possessed. That direct-to-camera monolog was devastating. But Oscar voters blinked. Missed the bullseye. Again.

Delroy Lindo, Da 5 BloodsDa 5 Bloods Movie Clip - Ghosts (2020) | Movieclips Coming Soon by Rotten Tomatoes Coming Soon

Advertisement

Toni Collette, Hereditary

Nothing prepares you for that scream. Collette’s Annie in Hereditary shattered every horror archetype, balancing grief, terror, and sheer psychological collapse. The dinner table showdown alone was Oscar-worthy. Yet horror rarely gets respect at the Academy.

Advertisement

Her breakdown is permanently burned into the viewer’s brain.

Toni Collette, HereditaryHereditary | Toni Collette Terrifies | Official Promo HD | A24 by A24

Advertisement

Robert Pattinson, Good Time

Forget the vampire phase. Pattinson’s Connie in Good Time was frantic and heartbreakingly human. He tore through NYC’s underworld on one bad decision after another, gripping you the entire ride. He gave it his all. The industry barely blinked. Talk about a good time gone unrecognized.

Robert Pattinson, Good Time'Good Time' Official Trailer 2 (2017) | Robert Pattinson by Moviefone

Advertisement

Elisabeth Moss, Her Smell

Self-destruction oozed from every pore. Moss, playing punk rocker Becky Something, turned chaos into poetry in Her Smell. Her performance wasn’t pretty; it was volcanic. Wild stage energy.

Advertisement

Private meltdowns. Quiet redemption. No Oscar buzz, though. Maybe the role felt too real for comfort?

Elisabeth Moss, Her SmellHer Smell | OFFICIAL TRAILER HD by Gunpowder & Sky

Advertisement

Lakeith Stanfield, Sorry To Bother You

Lakeith slipped you into a bizarre world, then turned it upside down. In Sorry to Bother You, he nailed the corporate code-switch, rising from broke telemarketer to literal workhorse. His deadpan unraveling was unforgettable. The Oscars never picked up the phone.

Lakeith Stanfield, Sorry To Bother YouSORRY TO BOTHER YOU | Official Trailer by ANNAPURNA

Advertisement

Paul Giamatti, Sideways

Wine, heartbreak, and awkward honesty defined Giamatti’s Miles in Sideways. With every swirl and sniff, he poured emotion into his glass and the screen.

Advertisement

That “I am not drinking any f***ing Merlot” line? Iconic. Everyone toasted him—except 

Oscar voters. Still, Miles aged better than most winners.

Paul Giamatti, SidewaysSideways (1/5) Movie CLIP - Miles on Wine (2004) HD by Movieclips

Advertisement

Emily Blunt, A Quiet Place

In near silence, Blunt roared. Her performance in A Quiet Place hinged on terror, particularly in one unforgettable bathtub scene. Without a word, she made you hold your breath. The monster wasn’t the scariest part; the raw maternal fear was. No nomination?

Advertisement

Now that’s horror.

Emily Blunt, A Quiet PlaceA Quiet Place (2018) - Official Trailer - Paramount Pictures by Paramount Pictures

Advertisement

Oscar Isaac, Inside Llewyn Davis

Melancholy dripped from every note Isaac sang in Inside Llewyn Davis. His struggling folk musician wandered through loss and loneliness with haunting realism. The cat. The couch-surfing. The subway stares. He deserved more than critical whispers. Llewyn may have stayed broke, but Isaac left rich in performance.

Oscar Isaac, Inside Llewyn DavisInside Llewyn Davis - Official Trailer [HD] by CBS Films

Advertisement

Rosamund Pike, Gone Girl

Vengeance never looked so calculated. Pike’s Amy in Gone Girl oozed intellect, ice, and manipulation. From diary pages to blood-slicked revenge, she reinvented the “cool girl” myth with chilling flair. Nominated, yes.

Advertisement

But she made sociopathy seductive and walked away without the prize.

Rosamund Pike, Gone GirlGone Girl Movie CLIP - Who Are You? (2014) - Rosamund Pike, Ben Affleck Movie HD by Rotten Tomatoes Coming Soon

Advertisement

Michael B Jordan, Creed

Legacy and grit met in Jordan’s Adonis Creed. He punched harder emotionally than physically, honoring his roots while forging his name. Every training montage hit deeper because you saw the weight he carried. And yet? Stallone got the nod. Jordan did the lifting.

Michael B Jordan, CreedCREED III Clip - "You've Got To Open Up" (2023) Michael B. Jordan by JoBlo Movie Clips

Advertisement

Scarlett Johansson, Under the Skin

Alien, seductive, and silent—Johansson gave a masterclass in minimalism in Under the Skin. She wandered Scotland like a blank slate, where she absorbed humanity through eerie encounters.

Advertisement

No dialogue. Just haunting stares and slow seduction. She vanished into the role, and the Academy...vanished from the conversation.

Scarlett Johansson, Under The SkinUnder The Skin | Official Trailer HD | A24 by A24

Advertisement

Hugh Jackman, Prisoners

Rage ran hot and wild in Jackman’s portrayal of Keller Dover in Prisoners. A desperate father hunting his daughter’s kidnapper, he teetered between savior and monster. The tension never let go, and neither did he. But the statue? Gone without a trace.

Hugh Jackman, PrisonersPrisoners Official Trailer #1 (2013) - Hugh Jackman, Jake Gyllenhaal Movie HD by Rotten Tomatoes Trailers

Advertisement

READ MORE

Nepo Internal
January 23, 2024 Eul Basa

These Nepo Babies Are Hollywood's Next Big Stars

With every generation of celebrities, the limelight will always shine on "nepo babies" first—these people were born into money, with their paths paved by the reputations of their distinguished relatives.
Simpsons Internal
February 23, 2024 Sammy Tran

Scary Predictions On The Simpsons That Actually Came True

Through the decades, "The Simpsons" has made some disturbingly precise future forecasts, leaving audiences in awe and amazement.
Bloopers Internal
February 16, 2024 Eul Basa

10 Famous Movie Bloopers That Made The Final Cut

Sometimes, bloopers end up being unanticipated treasures that actually improve a film and add an element of realness to an otherwise cut-and-dry story.
Oscars Internal
February 20, 2024 Sammy Tran

10 Most Awkward Moments At The Oscars

The Oscars may be Hollywood's biggest night, but even it is not immune to shocking moments.
Musicianswithoscars Internal
January 24, 2024 Peter Kinney

From Stage To Screen: Musicians with Oscars

Though most people identify the Academy Awards with an actor’s accomplishments in film, several musicians have also won the coveted golden statuette.
Realitytv Internal
February 26, 2024 Eul Basa

These Unscripted Reality TV Moments Had Us Shook

There have been several moments in the crazy world of reality television that viewers will never forget.