They Could Handle The West

Classic Westerns weren't exclusively populated by stoic cowboys and gunslingers. Some of the genre's toughest characters were women who ran ranches, faced down outlaws, survived unforgiving journeys, and occasionally outshot the men. These performances proved that women were able to carve out a place for themselves in the Old West without waiting around for a man to come and save them. (Above: Gene Tierney in Belle Starr)

Donaldson Collection/Getty Images

Marlene Dietrich—Destry Rides Again

Marlene Dietrich revitalized her career as saloon singer Frenchy in George Marshall's Destry Rides Again (1939), opposite James Stewart. Brash, funny, fearless, and perfectly willing to brawl with Una Merkel's Lily Belle, Frenchy could dominate a saloon before ultimately demonstrating that her courage went considerably deeper than swagger.

Screenshot from Destry Rides Again, Universal Pictures (1939)

Barbara Stanwyck—The Furies

Barbara Stanwyck made Western toughness look effortless as fiercely independent rancher's daughter Vance Jeffords in Anthony Mann's The Furies (1950). Opposite Walter Huston in his final film role, Stanwyck created a heroine capable of matching her domineering father in ambition, anger, stubbornness, and sheer force of personality.

Screenshot from The Furies, Paramount Pictures (1950)

Marlene Dietrich—Rancho Notorious

Dietrich returned to the West as Altar Keane in Fritz Lang's psychologically dark Rancho Notorious (1952), opposite Arthur Kennedy and Mel Ferrer. She runs the Chuck-a-Luck ranch, a hideout for wanted men, and commands the place with an authority that makes her considerably more formidable than most conventional Western heroines.

Screenshot from Rancho Notorious, RKO Radio Pictures (1952)

Joan Crawford—Johnny Guitar

Joan Crawford's Vienna doesn't merely survive Nicholas Ray's extraordinary Johnny Guitar (1954). She dominates it. The saloon owner faces a hostile mob led by Mercedes McCambridge's equally ferocious Emma Small, while Sterling Hayden's title character almost gets relegated to the supporting cast in a Western ultimately driven by two exceptionally powerful women.

Screenshot from Johnny Guitar (1954)

Mercedes McCambridge—Johnny Guitar

Mercedes McCambridge deserves her own place for Johnny Guitar (1954). Emma is unquestionably a villain, but toughness doesn't require heroism. Bitter, obsessive, and frighteningly persuasive, she can turn respectable townspeople into a murderous posse. McCambridge matches Crawford's enormous screen presence and helps create the Western's unforgettable female showdown. McCambridge and Crawford's offscreen battles also became a part of Hollywood legend, but that's a story for another time.

Screenshot from Johnny Guitar, Republic Pictures (1954)

Barbara Stanwyck—Cattle Queen Of Montana

Barbara Stanwyck saddled up opposite Ronald Reagan in Allan Dwan's Cattle Queen of Montana (1954). As Martha Cutting, she returns to Montana determined to reclaim her murdered father's ranch and stolen cattle. Stanwyck's ease around horses and natural authority made this kind of fiercely independent Western woman especially convincing.

Screenshot from Cattle Queen of Montana, RKO Radio Pictures (1954)

Ruth Roman—The Far Country

Ruth Roman played Leah Fuller in Anthony Mann's The Far Country (1954), opposite James Stewart. The tough-minded frontier woman operates in the dangerous Yukon world surrounding Stewart's cynical cattleman Jeff Webster. Roman had already accumulated considerable Western experience, and Leah possesses the independence necessary to stand beside Mann's unusually hard-edged hero.

Screenshot from The Far Country, Universal Pictures (1954)

Gene Tierney—Belle Starr

Gene Tierney brought beauty and defiance to Irving Cummings's Belle Starr (1941), playing the legendary outlaw opposite Randolph Scott and Dana Andrews. Her Southern aristocrat turns against occupying authorities after the Civil War and joins the notorious Starr band, giving the young Tierney an unusually forceful early starring role.

Screenshot from Belle Starr, 20th Century Fox (1941)

Claire Trevor—Stagecoach

Claire Trevor's Dallas in John Ford's Stagecoach (1939) would chronologically come earlier, but she deserves special recognition among Western survivors. Ostracized by supposedly respectable society and forced onto a dangerous Apache-country journey, Dallas displays compassion and resilience while John Wayne's Ringo Kid gradually recognizes the dignity others refuse to see.

Image credit

Dorothy Malone—The Last Sunset

Dorothy Malone brought considerable steel to Delmer Daves's The Last Sunset (1961), starring Rock Hudson and Kirk Douglas. As Belle Breckenridge, she is caught between dangerous men and buried secrets while crossing harsh Western country, demonstrating the emotional toughness often demanded from women in adult, psychologically complicated Westerns.

Screenshot from The Last Sunset, Universal Pictures (1961)

Katy Jurado—High Noon

Katy Jurado's Helen Ramirez in Fred Zinnemann's High Noon (1952) is tougher than most of the townsmen abandoning Gary Cooper's Marshal Will Kane. A successful businesswoman and former lover of Kane and outlaw Frank Miller, Helen understands danger clearly and refuses to pretend cowardice is respectable simply because everyone else does.

Screenshot from High Noon, United Artists (1952)

Olive Carey—The Searchers

Olive Carey has comparatively little screen time in John Ford's The Searchers (1956), but Mrs. Jorgensen embodies frontier endurance. While John Wayne's Ethan Edwards obsessively searches for Debbie, the older women of the community endure death, isolation, raids, and years of uncertainty while keeping families and settlements functioning.

Screenshot from The Searchers, Warner Bros. (1956)

Natalie Wood—The Searchers

Natalie Wood's Debbie in John Ford's The Searchers (1956) represents a different kind of survival. Abducted as a child and raised among the Comanche, she becomes the focus of Ethan Edwards's obsessive search. Her continued existence challenges Ethan's prejudices and ultimately forces him to choose humanity over vengeance.

Screenshot from The Searchers, Warner Bros. (1956)

Barbara Stanwyck—Forty Guns

Few Western women make an entrance like Barbara Stanwyck's Jessica Drummond in Samuel Fuller's Forty Guns (1957). The powerful Arizona rancher commands 40 armed men and effectively rules Cochise County. Stanwyck even performed demanding riding work herself, reinforcing Jessica's image as somebody entirely comfortable exercising traditionally masculine authority.

Screenshot from Forty Guns, 20th Century Fox (1957)

Hope Emerson—Westward The Women

At 6-foot-2, Hope Emerson had the physical presence for a Western, but her performance as widowed sea captain's wife Patience Hawley in William A. Wellman's Westward the Women (1951) offers much more. Traveling with Robert Taylor's wagon train of prospective brides, Patience becomes a tough, practical, protective presence as the women master shooting, animals, wagons, and the brutal overland journey.

Unknown authorUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Raquel Welch—Hannie Caulder

Raquel Welch gave the revenge Western a female gunslinger in Burt Kennedy's Hannie Caulder (1971). After horrific violence destroys her old life, Hannie persuades Robert Culp's bounty hunter Thomas Luther Price to teach her to shoot. She then sets out after the three Clemens brothers responsible.

Screenshot from Hannie Caulder, Paramount Pictures (1971)

Shirley MacLaine—Two Mules For Sister Sara

Shirley MacLaine's Sister Sara in Don Siegel's Two Mules for Sister Sara (1970) initially appears to be a helpless nun rescued by Clint Eastwood's mercenary Hogan. That impression doesn't last. Resourceful, profane in unexpected ways, and surrounded by secrets, Sara repeatedly proves perfectly capable of surviving revolutionary Mexico.

Screenshot from Two Mules for Sister Sara, Universal Pictures (1970)

Claudia Cardinale—Once Upon A Time In The West

Claudia Cardinale's Jill McBain is the emotional center of Sergio Leone's Once Upon a Time in the West (1968). Arriving to find her new family murdered, Jill refuses to surrender their valuable land. Opposite Henry Fonda, Charles Bronson, and Jason Robards, Cardinale embodies survival rather than gunfighter bravado.

Screenshot from Once Upon a Time in the West, Paramount Pictures (1968)

Katy Jurado—Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid

Katy Jurado brought tremendous authority to Sam Peckinpah's Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1973), just as she had throughout her Western career. Jurado's importance to the genre extended beyond any single character. She repeatedly played women who seemed to understand the Western world more clearly than the men destroying themselves within it.

Screenshot from Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (1973)

Kim Darby—True Grit

Kim Darby's Mattie Ross drives Henry Hathaway's True Grit (1969). The determined teenager hires John Wayne's Rooster Cogburn to pursue her father's killer, then insists on joining the hunt herself. Surrounded by armed men, criminals, wilderness, and danger, Mattie repeatedly refuses to be dismissed because of her age or gender.

Screenshot from True Grit, Paramount Pictures (1969)

Katharine Ross—Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid

Katharine Ross brought intelligence and composure to Etta Place in George Roy Hill's Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969). Opposite Paul Newman and Robert Redford, Etta recognizes the danger surrounding the charming outlaws more clearly than they do and ultimately possesses the strength to walk away from their doomed adventure.

Screenshot from Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, 20th Century Fox (1969)

Jane Fonda—Cat Ballou

Jane Fonda's Catherine Ballou evolves dramatically in Elliot Silverstein's comic Western Cat Ballou (1965). Beginning as an aspiring schoolteacher, Cat turns outlaw after her father's murder and recruits Lee Marvin's spectacularly drunken gunfighter Kid Shelleen. Fonda keeps Cat determined and capable even amid the movie's broad comedy.

Screenshot from Cat Ballou, Columbia Pictures (1965)

Samantha Eggar—The Man Who Loved Cat Dancing

Samantha Eggar's Sarah Carver endures one of the genre's most grueling journeys in Richard C. Sarafian's The Man Who Loved Cat Dancing (1973), opposite Burt Reynolds. Frontier toughness isn't always about winning gunfights. Sometimes it means surviving dangerous men, punishing landscapes, and circumstances offering almost no good choices.

CBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Eva Marie Saint—The Stalking Moon

Eva Marie Saint brought a very different toughness to Robert Mulligan's The Stalking Moon (1968), opposite Gregory Peck. Her character Sarah Carver has survived years of captivity among the Apache and desperately tries to protect her son from his pursuing father. Fear never prevents her from fighting for the boy.

Screenshot of Eva Marie Saint in The Stalking Moon (1968), National General Pictures, enhanced

Julie Christie—McCabe & Mrs. Miller

Julie Christie transformed the familiar Western madam into something considerably more formidable in Robert Altman's McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971). Warren Beatty's McCabe may imagine himself the entrepreneur, but Mrs. Miller is the sharper business mind, turning their rough establishment into a profitable operation while understanding its dangers far better.

Screenshot from McCabe & Mrs. Miller, Warner Bros. (1971)

Vera Miles—The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

Vera Miles played one of John Ford's strongest later Western women in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962). As Hallie Stoddard, she stands between James Stewart's idealistic Ransom Stoddard and John Wayne's Tom Doniphon, while her education and choices quietly symbolize the West's transition from violence toward civilization.

Screenshot from The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, Paramount Pictures (1962)

Sophia Loren—Heller In Pink Tights

Sophia Loren brought star power and considerable physical resilience to George Cukor's Heller in Pink Tights (1960), while her Western contemporaries increasingly demonstrated that female characters could occupy territory beyond schoolmarms and saloon girls. The genre was gradually making room for women whose ambitions actually drove the story.

Screenshot from Heller in Pink Tights, Paramount Pictures (1960)

Maureen O'Hara—Big Jake

Maureen O'Hara was practically built for Western defiance, and in George Sherman's Big Jake (1971) she played Martha McCandles opposite longtime friend John Wayne. When their grandson is kidnapped, Martha doesn't collapse. She takes command, raises the ransom, and summons her estranged husband to bring the boy home.

Screenshot from Big Jake, National General Pictures (1971)

The Toughest Of Them

These women demonstrate why "tough" means much more than carrying a Colt. Vienna commands a saloon, Jessica Drummond commands an army, Mattie Ross demands justice, Jill McBain refuses to surrender her future, and Frenchy physically fights when necessary. The best Western women didn't merely survive men's stories. They transformed them.

Screenshot from True Grit, Paramount Pictures (1969)

You May Also Like:

Actresses Who Appeared In The Most Westerns—How Many Do You Remember?

Child Stars From Classic Westerns. Where Did They Go?

Katharine Ross became a Western legend, but her fierce independence came at a cost.

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7