Stage Actors Who Were So Good On Broadway, Hollywood Had To Put Them In A Movie

Sometimes Hollywood doesn't need a casting search. The perfect performer is already winning over Broadway audiences. From dramatic breakthroughs to blockbuster musicals, these actors proved that a great stage performance could become an equally unforgettable movie moment.

Geraldine Page in 1956

From Stage To Screen

Sometimes Hollywood doesn't need a casting search. The perfect performer is already winning over Broadway audiences. From dramatic breakthroughs to blockbuster musicals, these actors proved that a great stage performance could become an equally unforgettable movie moment.

Geraldine Page in 1956press photo, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Marlon Brando

Brando electrified Broadway as Stanley Kowalski in Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire. Director Elia Kazan brought him into the 1951 film, preserving his celebrated 1947 stage performance. Moviegoers finally saw that Stanley firsthand.

Portrait of Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named DesireCarl Van Vechten, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Shirley Booth

Booth had already won a Tony for playing Lola in Come Back, Little Sheba when the film came calling. Her 1953 movie performance earned an Academy Award for Best Actress. Two triumphs, one character.

Press photo of Shirley Booth in the American drama film Come Back, Little Sheba (1953).Paramount Pictures press photo, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Ethel Merman

Call Me Madam was written for Merman's voice, and Broadway audiences knew why. When the Irving Berlin musical became a 1953 movie, she returned as Sally Adams, preserving the show's defining performer. Nobody had to imitate her.

Publicity photo of Ethel Merman from her performance in Call Me Madam. The photo was used to promote her guest appearance on ABC TV's Batman in 1967.ABC Television, Wikimedia Commons, Modified

Advertisement

Vivian Blaine

As Miss Adelaide in Guys and Dolls, Blaine made the musical a sensation. She was among the original cast members invited into the 1955 film, sharing the screen with Marlon Brando and Frank Sinatra in her signature role. Her Adelaide was already a crowd favorite.

Viviane Blaine Sam Levene in the Original Broadway Production of Guys and DollsAnonymous, Wikimedia Commons, Enhanced

Advertisement

Yul Brynner

Brynner first ruled Broadway as the King of Siam in The King and I. In the 1956 film, he kept the crown opposite Deborah Kerr. He won an Academy Award.

Screenshot from The King and I (1956)Screenshot from The King and I, 20th Century-Fox (1956), Enhanced

Advertisement

Sidney Poitier

Poitier originated Walter Lee Younger on Broadway in Lorraine Hansberry's A Raisin in the Sun. He reunited with several castmates for the 1961 film, bringing the character's ambitions and family tensions to film audiences. His Broadway work had earned another audience.

Photo of a scene from the play A Raisin in the Sun.  From left-Louis Gossett (George Murchison), Ruby Dee (Ruth Younger) and Sidney Poitier (Walter Younger). Everyone shown in the photo reprised their roles in the 1961 film.Friedman-Abeles, New York, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Geraldine Page

Hollywood considered established screen stars for Alexandra Del Lago in Sweet Bird of Youth. But Page had originated the part on Broadway, and she ultimately reprised it opposite Paul Newman in the 1962 film. Experience won.

Screenshot from Sweet Bird of Youth (1962)Screenshot from Sweet Bird of Youth, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (1962)

Advertisement

Anne Bancroft

Bancroft's portrayal of teacher Annie Sullivan made The Miracle Worker a Broadway powerhouse. She returned for the 1962 film with director Arthur Penn and Patty Duke. The movie earned Bancroft an Oscar for Best Actress.

Screenshot from The Miracle Worker (1962)Screenshot from The Miracle Worker, United Artists (1962)

Advertisement

Patty Duke

Duke spent nineteen months onstage portraying Helen Keller in The Miracle Worker. Rather than replace the young actress for the screen, the filmmakers brought her along. Her 1962 performance won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress.

Screenshot from The Miracle Worker (1962)Screenshot from The Miracle Worker, United Artists (1962)

Advertisement

Robert Preston

Broadway audiences knew Preston as the gloriously persuasive Harold Hill in The Music Man. He originated the role in 1957, won a Tony, and reprised the traveling salesman in the 1962 film. Hollywood kept its convincing con man.

Screenshot from The Music Man (1962) Screenshot from The Music Man, Warner Bros. Pictures (1962)

Advertisement

Dick Van Dyke

His Tony-winning turn as Albert Peterson helped make Bye Bye Birdie a Broadway hit. In 1963, Van Dyke brought the role to the big screen for his feature-film debut. Broadway handed Hollywood a musical comedy star.

Dick Van Dyke  517323182Bettman, Getty Images

Advertisement

Julie Andrews

Andrews didn't repeat her Broadway character on film, but her stage work opened another door. Walt Disney saw her play Guinevere in Camelot and offered her Mary Poppins. The 1964 movie introduced her spectacularly to film audiences.

Screenshot of Julie Andrews from the trailer for the film Mary PoppinsDisney trailer screenshot, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Rex Harrison

Harrison originated Professor Henry Higgins in the 1956 Broadway production of My Fair Lady. Warner Bros. kept him for its lavish 1964 adaptation, although Audrey Hepburn replaced stage costar Julie Andrews. His delivery remained the anchor.

Screenshot from My Fair Lady (1964)Screenshot from My Fair Lady, Warner Bros. Pictures (1964)

Advertisement

Barbra Streisand

Funny Girl transformed Streisand into a Broadway sensation when it opened in 1964. Four years later, she made her movie debut playing Fanny Brice again. She won the Oscar for Best Actress.

Screenshot from Funny Girl (1968)Screenshot from Funny Girl, Columbia Pictures (1968)

Advertisement

James Earl Jones

Jones commanded Broadway as boxer Jack Jefferson in The Great White Hope, winning a Tony for his performance. He took the same character into the 1970 film, earning an Oscar nomination. His Broadway triumph became a Hollywood showcase.

Screenshot from The Great White Hope (1970)Screenshot from The Great White Hope, 20th Century-Fox (1970), Enhanced

Advertisement

Jane Alexander

Alexander starred opposite James Earl Jones in The Great White Hope and won a Tony as Eleanor Bachman. She joined him for the 1970 movie, earning an Oscar nomination for her screen debut. One play, two film breakthroughs.

Screenshot from The Great White Hope (1970)Screenshot from The Great White Hope, 20th Century-Fox (1970), Enhanced

Advertisement

Joel Grey

As Cabaret's mysterious Emcee, Grey made himself indispensable to the original Broadway musical. Bob Fosse retained him for the 1972 film, where the performance earned Grey an Oscar. He won both a Tony and an Oscar for the character.

Joel Grey In Cabaret 688004817Silver Screen Collection, Getty Images

Advertisement

William Daniels

Long before television audiences knew him as Mr. Feeny, Daniels played John Adams in Broadway's 1776. The 1972 film brought back much of the theater cast, including Daniels. His impatient founding father was well tested.

Screenshot from 1776 (1972)Screenshot from 1776, Columbia Pictures (1972)

Advertisement

Ted Ross

The Wiz had a substantially different film cast, but Ross kept his role as the Cowardly Lion. He originated the character in 1975 and returned when the film arrived in 1978. The Lion remained his.

Screenshot from The Wiz (1978)Screenshot from The Wiz, Universal Pictures (1978)

Advertisement

Harvey Fierstein

Fierstein didn't simply star in Torch Song Trilogy; he wrote it. The Broadway production brought him Tony Awards for Best Play and Leading Actor. For the 1988 movie, he again played Arnold Beckoff, bringing his creation to film.

Screenshot from Torch Song Trilogy (1988)Screenshot from Torch Song Trilogy, New Line Cinema (1988), Enhanced

Advertisement

Anthony Rapp

Rapp originated aspiring filmmaker Mark Cohen in the 1996 Broadway production of Rent. For the 2005 movie, the filmmakers brought back six original cast members. Rapp kept the show's narrator intact.

Screenshot from Rent (2005) Credit: Screenshot from Rent, Columbia Pictures (2005)Screenshot from Rent, Columbia Pictures (2005)

Advertisement

Idina Menzel

Before Wicked made her a Broadway phenomenon, Menzel originated Maureen Johnson in Rent. She returned to the character in the 2005 film alongside several original castmates. The movie captured her familiar stage performance.

Screenshot from Rent (2005)Screenshot from Rent, Columbia Pictures (2005)

Advertisement

Nathan Lane

Lane's explosive portrayal of Max Bialystock helped turn The Producers into a record-breaking Broadway hit. The 2005 film version kept him in the role, alongside his stage partner Matthew Broderick. Brooks' showman remained in familiar hands.

Screenshot from The Producers (2005)Screenshot from The Producers, Universal Pictures (2005)

Advertisement

Matthew Broderick

As nervous accountant Leo Bloom, Broderick provided the perfect counterweight to Nathan Lane's Max in The Producers. The partners recreated their Broadway chemistry for the 2005 movie musical. Recasting the duo would have been a gamble.

Screenshot from The Producers (2005)Screenshot from The Producers, Universal Pictures (2005)

Advertisement

John Lloyd Young

Young won a Tony playing Frankie Valli in Jersey Boys, then reprised the role in Clint Eastwood's 2014 film. He later said the movie gave him room to explore details the stage script couldn't accommodate. Broadway supplied the experience.

Screenshot from Jersey Boys (2014) Screenshot from Jersey Boys, Warner Bros. Pictures (2014)

Advertisement

Denzel Washington

Washington earned a Tony playing Troy Maxson in the 2010 Broadway revival of August Wilson's Fences. Six years later, he directed its film adaptation and starred in it. He returned to a character he knew intimately.

Screenshot from Fences (2016)Screenshot from Fences, Paramount Pictures (2016)

Advertisement

Viola Davis

Davis won a Tony for playing Rose Maxson opposite Washington in Fences. When the production reached theaters in 2016, she brought that powerhouse performance with her. The film earned Davis an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress, completing her stage-to-screen journey.

Screenshot from Fences (2016)Screenshot from Fences, Paramount Pictures (2016)

Advertisement

Ben Platt

Platt originated the title character in Dear Evan Hansen and won a Tony for his Broadway performance. He returned for the 2021 film adaptation, years after developing the role. The casting preserved the musical's original leading man.

Screenshot from Dear Evan Hansen (2021)Screenshot from Dear Evan Hansen, Universal Pictures (2021)

Advertisement

Fantasia Barrino

Barrino made her Broadway debut as Celie in The Color Purple in 2007. She initially hesitated about revisiting the part for the 2023 movie musical but ultimately accepted. Her film debut revisited her breakthrough theater role.

Screenshot from The Color Purple (2023)Screenshot from The Color Purple, Warner Bros. Pictures (2023)

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

Why Pernell Roberts Walked Away From Bonanza While It Was Still A Massive Hit

Kim Novak And Sammy Davis Jr. Embarked On A Dangerous Love Affair That Ended In A Near-Death Disaster.

Celebrities In The 1970s Who Appeared On The Muppet Show—And The Muppets Brought Out A Whole New Side Of Them

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26


✕