There Wasn’t Much She Couldn’t Do
Suzanne Pleshette was an actress who defied easy labels. Etched in most people’s memory as Emily Hartley on The Bob Newhart Show, her career spanned Broadway, Hitchcock thrillers, 60s romances, Emmy-nominated dramas, and acclaimed voice work. Versatility was what Suzanne was all about, marking her resilience and presence both on and off screen.
Early Roots And Training
Born January 31, 1937, in Brooklyn, Suzanne Pleshette trained at the High School of Performing Arts and the Neighborhood Playhouse under Sanford Meisner. Stage discipline, projection, and her unmistakably husky voice were assets she would put to good use across theater, film, and television, setting her up for a great start to her career.
First Steps On The Stage
Pleshette made her Broadway debut in 1957 with Compulsion, and soon proved herself as a promising young performer. New York critics complimented her poise, timing, and ability to command a room without over-emoting. Those stage chops would drive her screen presence soon after.
United Artists, Wikimedia Commons
First Film And TV Roles
Her screen debut came with Jerry Lewis’s The Geisha Boy (1958), and that was followed by a steady stream of television work in the early 60s. She bounced easily back and forth between guest TV appearances and film supporting roles, earning a reputation for intelligence and dry wit. The industry couldn’t help but take note: she could play warmth, bite, or a little bit of both!
Breakout In Rome
In Rome Adventure (1962), Pleshette played opposite off-screen lover and future husband Troy Donahue, blending romantic atmosphere with gritty realism. The film helped build her profile from “talented newcomer” to bankable presence. Her on-screen profile had finally set the table for a different kind of challenge.
Warner Bros., Rome Adventure (1962)
Hitchcock Calls: The Birds
Alfred Hitchcock cast Pleshette as Annie Hayworth in The Birds (1963), a role demanding vulnerability without melodrama. She shaded Annie with a slight air of resignation and quiet courage, giving the film a solid mooring of determination amid the fear and chaos. Working under Hitchcock’s exacting eye honed her instincts for subtlety.
Universal Pictures, The Birds (1963)
A Sixties Film Identity
Through the rest of the 60s, Pleshette built an impressive film résumé—romances, dramas, westerns, and comedies—without letting herself get hemmed in by any one character type. She moved from polished leads to textured supporting characters, and showed producers she could add vitality to middling material and give some texture to good scripts. By decade’s end, she was regarded as one of the most versatile performers in the business.
ABC Television, Wikimedia Commons
Television As A Second Home
TV’s variety was great for Suzanne: she could be flinty and tough one week and empathetic the next. Directors could have confidence in her timing and composure under quick schedules. Pleshette had enough experience by the early 70s that she could walk onto any set and excel—it was a skill that would pay off spectacularly as the decade went on.
Landing The Bob Newhart Show
In 1972, host Johnny Carson invited Pleshette onto The Tonight Show along with Bob Newhart. The two had already known each other for years, and they got along famous on the show. CBS producers couldn’t fail to see the on-screen chemistry between the pair; they offered Suzanne the role as Emily, the wife of Newhart’s character Bob Hartley. She fulfilled their high expectations and then some.
CBS Television, Wikimedia Commons
A TV Couple
Pleshette and Newhart crafted a modern on-screen marriage of equals. Her laconic charm, comedic sense, and emotional steadiness made Emily the show’s center of gravity. The easy unrehearsed chemistry between the two of them did the rest: the couple felt natural, witty, and real.
CBS, The Bob Newhart Show (1972–1978)
Defining Emily Hartley
Emily wasn’t a sitcom prop; Pleshette played her as smart, amused, and occasionally exasperated, but never bitter. She matched Newhart’s dry humor beat for beat. She earned two Emmy nominations, but the real payoff was in the memories of audiences: Pleshette and Newhart were still recalled by fans with fondness decades afterward.
CBS, The Bob Newhart Show (1972–1978)
She Wasn’t Slowing Down
Even at Newhart’s peak, Pleshette kept a demanding schedule of TV movies, stage revivals, and comedy films. There was no danger of her being typecast with all the different roles she took on.
Relationships And Hollywood Spotlight
After Pleshette’s marriage to Troy Donahue fizzled out, she went on to wed businessman Tom Gallagher in 1968, a long, private marriage that lasted until his passing in 2000. In 2001, she married longtime friend and fellow Newhart actor Tom Poston, a late-in-life partnership fans adored.
Ron Galella, Ltd., Getty Images
Queen Of Mean: A Darker Role
Pleshette’s acclaimed turn as Leona Helmsley in Leona Helmsley: The Queen of Mean (1990) showcased her dramatic steel. She elevated her portrayal of an unpopular person from shallow tabloid caricature to a recognizable human being, earning Emmy and Golden Globe nominations for her effort. The performance was a reminder of her long and accomplished track record and abilities.
Leona Helmsley: The Queen of Mean part 1, Drama Channel
Animation Royalty: A Voice To Remember
Pleshette’s contralto voice powered a late-career shift to voice work: Zira in The Lion King II: Simba’s Pride (1998) and Yubaba/Zeniba in Spirited Away’s English dub (2002).
Walt Disney Pictures, The Lion King II: Simba’s Pride (1998)
Later-Career TV Guest Spots
Pleshette had some memorable roles through the ’90s and 2000s, that included The Boys Are Back (1994–95) where she co-starred with Hal Linden; Good Morning, Miami (2002–03); and Will & Grace (2002–04). She was always a welcome face for older viewers, while she made the acquaintance of a new generation.
How She Chose Roles
Across different mediums, she picked parts with agency: women making choices and living with them. If the writing was smart or the collaborator interesting, she was always up for the challenge of something different. It was that curiosity that made her filmography so eclectic, and it’s a big part of why so many of her projects from different eras still feel fresh.
Silver Screen Collection, Getty Images
Public Poise, Private Strength
Behind the scenes, she navigated the lung cancer that afflicted her final years with candor and grit, continuing to work while guarding privacy. Friends and collaborators recalled her wicked humor and zero pretense. Her personality made her a favorite on sets and on TV talk shows for decades.
She Outshone The Emily Effect
Though most remembered her as Emily Hartley, Pleshette’s legacy is breadth: Hitchcock heroine, 60s screen lead, Emmy-nominated antihero, voice-acting icon. Rather than shy away from the role that made her famous, she built a career strong enough to add it to her other accomplishments as only one pillar among many.
Jean-Paul Aussenard, Getty Images
Final Years And Farewell
After Tom Poston passed on in 2007, Pleshette herself lost her life a year later at 70, following lung cancer treatment; the industry’s tributes acclaimed her generosity and grit. Even in later appearances, her voice and presence were unmistakable. The formidable body of work is still there, along with the sense that she never wasted a moment as the years flew by.
Michael Caulfield Archive, Getty Images
The Thread That Traces Through It All
From Compulsion to The Birds, from Emily Hartley to Leona Helmsley, from Disney villains to Miyazaki’s witch, Pleshette’s fine strand was control of tone, timing, and self. She didn’t have just one career, but several. And she excelled in every one of them.
You May Also Like:
The Most Unexpected Guest Stars In Sitcom History
Chilling Facts About Alfred Hitchcock, The Dark Genius
The Long Career and Too-Short Life of TV’s Fugitive, David Janssen
