When “Watch Anytime” Became “Why Am I Still Watching This?”
Streaming was supposed to free us from appointment television, endless reruns, and whatever random procedural happened to be on at 9pm. Instead, it’s given us something arguably worse: shows that look prestige-y, sound expensive, and somehow still feel like background noise you didn’t ask for. Cable at least knew what it was. These shows? They often aim high, miss wildly, and leave viewers nostalgic for the days when changing the channel was easier than committing to eight disappointing episodes.
Below are 21 streaming shows that, for various reasons, reminded us that unlimited choice doesn’t always mean better television.
FUBAR
Arnold Schwarzenegger returning to TV should’ve been a victory lap. Instead, FUBAR landed somewhere between spy spoof and dad sitcom, never fully committing to either. The jokes were broad, the action was forgettable, and the novelty wore off fast. For a show with this much star power, it felt oddly disposable.
Screenshot from FUBAR, Netflix (2023–2025)
Ultraman
Netflix’s take on the legendary Japanese franchise looked slick but struggled to justify its existence. The emotional beats rarely landed, and the storytelling felt stretched thin. Longtime fans weren’t thrilled, and newcomers had little reason to stick around. It’s a reminder that not every global IP needs a prestige reboot.
Screenshot from Ultraman, Netflix (2019–2023)
The Recruit
On paper, a CIA rookie stumbling into dangerous territory sounds like a solid binge. In practice, The Recruit leaned too hard on familiar tropes without adding much personality. The pacing dragged, the twists felt predictable, and the tone never quite settled. It wasn’t unwatchable—just aggressively forgettable.
Screenshot from The Recruit, Netflix (2022–2025)
Ginny & Georgia (Later Seasons)
The early buzz around Ginny & Georgia faded as later seasons doubled down on melodrama without deepening its characters. What once felt sharp and messy in a compelling way began to feel repetitive. It became a show that confused intensity for development.
Screenshot from Ginny & Georgia, Netflix (2021–)
Iron Fist Season 2
Marvel’s Netflix era had highs and lows, but Iron Fist never fully recovered from its shaky start. Season 2 tried to course-correct but couldn’t overcome lingering issues with pacing, characterization, and action. By then, viewers were already checking out.
Screenshot from Iron Fist, Netflix (2017–2018)
The I-Land
Few Netflix originals collapsed as quickly as The I-Land. What started as a mysterious survival drama unraveled into something genuinely baffling. Tonal shifts, clumsy twists, and underdeveloped ideas made it hard to take seriously. It’s often remembered less as a show and more as a cautionary tale.
Screenshot from The I-Land, Netflix (2019)
The Witcher Season 3
Once one of Netflix’s crown jewels, The Witcher stumbled badly in its third season. Storylines felt fragmented, character motivations grew muddy, and fans sensed the cracks behind the scenes. Losing goodwill is easier than earning it, and this season proved that.
Screenshot from The Witcher, Netflix (2019–)
Too Hot To Handle: Brazil
Reality TV has a low bar, but even by those standards, this spinoff felt unnecessary. The format offered few surprises, and cultural tweaks weren’t enough to justify the repetition. It played like content made to fill a content quota.
Screenshot from Too Hot To Handle: Brazil, Netflix (2021–2022)
The Midnight Club
Mike Flanagan’s young-adult horror series had atmosphere to spare but struggled with momentum. The storytelling felt uneven, and the emotional payoff didn’t always match the setup. For a creator known for slow-burn excellence, this one never quite ignited.
Screenshot from The Midnight Club, Netflix (2022)
Baby Reindeer
Ambitious and deeply personal, Baby Reindeer divided audiences with its intense subject matter and unsettling tone. While some praised its honesty, others found it exhausting rather than enlightening. It’s a show that demanded a lot from viewers—and didn’t always give enough back.
Screenshot from Baby Reindeer, Netflix (2024)
The Terminal List
Prime Video aimed for gritty military drama but delivered something closer to a power fantasy. Critics took issue with its blunt messaging and lack of nuance. What could’ve been complex instead felt strangely hollow.
Screenshot from The Terminal List, Amazon Prime Video (2022–)
Daisy Jones & The Six
With its starry cast and music-industry setting, expectations were sky-high. The series looked great but struggled to capture the emotional spark that made the source material beloved. It wasn’t terrible—it just never fully came alive.
Screenshot from Daisy Jones & The Six, Amazon Prime Video (2023)
The Legend Of Vox Machina Season 2
Season 1 surprised skeptics, but the follow-up didn’t hit as hard. The humor remained, but the storytelling felt less focused. For a show driven by fan passion, expectations may have simply outpaced execution.
Screenshot from The Legend of Vox Machina, Amazon Prime Video (2022–)
Mr. & Mrs. Smith
This reimagining tried to reinvent a familiar concept with mixed results. The chemistry was inconsistent, and the tone wobbled between satire and seriousness. It often felt like a stylish experiment that forgot to be fun.
Screenshot from Mr. & Mrs. Smith, Amazon Prime Video (2024-)
Harlem
Despite a promising premise, Harlem struggled to distinguish itself in a crowded genre. Character arcs felt undercooked, and storylines leaned on clichés. It wasn’t offensively bad—just frustratingly safe.
Screenshot from Harlem, Amazon Prime Video (2021–2025)
Constellation
Apple TV+ leaned into cerebral sci-fi, but Constellation buried its ideas under opaque storytelling. Viewers willing to do the homework were rewarded unevenly. For many, confusion outweighed intrigue.
Screenshot from Constellation, Apple TV+ (2024)
Palm Royale
Lavish production couldn’t save Palm Royale from feeling emotionally distant. The drama never quite justified its extravagance. It looked like prestige TV without the soul to match.
Screenshot from Palm Royale, Apple TV+ (2024–)
The New Look
Fashion history should be riveting, but The New Look felt oddly restrained. The performances were solid, yet the storytelling lacked urgency. It played more like a museum exhibit than a living drama.
Screenshot from The New Look, Apple TV+ (2024-)
Still Up
This late-night rom-com series had charm in theory but struggled to sustain momentum. The dialogue leaned quirky without landing enough genuine laughs. It felt like a show cable would’ve quietly canceled after one season.
Screenshot from Still Up, Apple TV+ (2023)
Shrinking
While not universally panned, Shrinking divided viewers with its tonal whiplash. Humor and grief collided in ways that didn’t always harmonize. For some, the imbalance made it emotionally confusing rather than cathartic.
Screenshot from Shrinking, Apple TV+ (2023–)
Cowboy Bebop
Netflix’s live-action adaptation became infamous almost instantly. Stylish visuals couldn’t mask awkward dialogue and tonal misfires. Fans of the original anime were unconvinced, newcomers were puzzled, and cancellation came swiftly.
Screenshot from Cowboy Bebop, Netflix (2021)
You May Also Like:
The Bittersweet Career and Life of Adam Rich
TV Spin-Offs We're Most Excited For In 2026
