Underrated Binge Material

Your next binge-watch might be hiding in television's graveyard. Brilliant writing, compelling characters, and innovative storytelling couldn't save these shows during their original runs. Now, they're waiting for rediscovery.

Galavant

Medieval knights rarely break into song, but ABC's Galavant made it work beautifully. This musical fantasy comedy ran 18 episodes across two seasons (2015–2016). It blended Monty Python-esque humor with Broadway-quality numbers that felt completely natural in its whimsical Seven Realms setting.

Galavant Trailer by IGN

Galavant (Cont.)

Joshua Sasse starred as the titular knight alongside Timothy Omundson's hilariously petulant King Richard, creating an odd couple dynamic that drove much of the show's charm. Despite critical acclaim and a devoted cult following, Galavant struggled with low ratings throughout its run. 

Galavant (Official HD Trailer) - Joshua Sasse by Trailers Center

The Dresden Files

Chicago's supernatural underbelly got the television treatment in 2007 with The Dresden Files, based on Jim Butcher's bestselling urban fantasy novels. However, the show suffered from severe mismanagement, including airing episodes out of order, which disrupted narrative cohesion and confused viewers.

Dresden Files trailer by vidbya

The Dresden Files (Cont.)

Blackthorne truly brought wizard-detective Dresden to life in this unique procedural that lasted a single season on the Sci-Fi Channel. What made it special was Dresden's dual approach. He used ancient spells and detective work to solve supernatural crimes plaguing Windy City.

Dresden Files trailer by vidbya

Revolution

What happens when all electricity mysteriously vanishes worldwide overnight? Eric Kripke explored this terrifying premise in Revolution (2012–2014). It was a post-apocalyptic drama produced alongside Jon Favreau. The nanite virus concept provided a fascinating backdrop for exploring humanity's struggle without modern conveniences.

Revolution - Official Trailer 2012 (Full HD) by verardy1

Revolution (Cont.)

Revolution initially struggled to find its identity during a rocky first season but featured compelling characters like Giancarlo Esposito's ruthlessly pragmatic Major Tom Neville. It was on screen for two full seasons before being canceled. Soon, passionate fan outcry led to a satisfying four-part comic series finale.

Revolution - Official Trailer 2012 (Full HD) by verardy1

Human Target

Mark Valley personified Christopher Chance, a bodyguard who literally becomes a "human target" to protect his clients from deadly threats. This DC Comics adaptation ran on Fox from 2010–2012, featuring shorter 10-episode seasons that allowed for spectacular action sequences.

HUMAN TARGET - Season 1 Trailer by GianniGuy

Human Target (Cont.)

The show improved significantly in its second season by adding Game of Thrones' Indira Varma and Salem's Janet Montgomery to the cast, bringing fresh dynamics to the team. Fox's decision to cancel it only came during the same brutal purge that claimed several other promising series.

HUMAN TARGET - Season 1 Trailer by GianniGuy

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

This is where Lena Headey brought fierce intensity to Sarah Connor. It continued the Terminator saga between the second and third films. The show followed Sarah and teenage John Connor as they battled Skynet's time-traveling assassins, aided by Cameron, a reprogrammed Terminator.

Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles (TV Series 2008-2009) | trailer by MDB trailers

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles (Cont.)

By the end of season two, the audience numbers were considered insufficient to justify continuation. Apparently, the series was relatively expensive for a network show, with a budget around $2.65 million per episode in the first season. Fox was reluctant to continue without strong ratings. 

Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles (TV Series 2008-2009) | trailer by MDB trailers

My So-Called Life

Claire Danes was just fifteen when she began portraying Angela Chase, an introspective teenager tackling high school's emotional minefield with remarkable authenticity. This 1994–1995 ABC drama said goodbye after 19 episodes but launched multiple careers and changed adolescent storytelling.

My So-Called Life : Jordan Catalano's love letter to Angela Chase.by Rofique Begum

My So-Called Life (Cont.)

The show's unflinchingly honest portrayal of teenage angst, first love, and identity struggles resonated deeply with audiences across multiple generations. On a side note, its raw emotional tone was seen as “dark” or “depressing” compared to lighter fare, contributing to its removal.

My So-Called Life : Jordan Catalano's love letter to Angela Chase.by Rofique Begum

Alphas

SyFy's superhero scenario changed dramatically when Alphas premiered in 2011, co-created by X-Men: The Last Stand screenwriter Zak Penn. It starred the brilliant David Strathairn. As a procedural drama, Alphas followed a CIA team investigating cases involving people with supernatural abilities and a realistic twist.

Alphas - Full Trailer by SeriesAddictSite

Alphas (Cont.)

Each Alpha's superpower came with devastating physical consequences—super strength damaged the heart, and mind control caused insanity. The show was SyFy's most-watched debut in years, yet ratings declined over two seasons before ending on a massive cliffhanger that even Sheldon Cooper couldn't overcome.

Alphas - Full Trailer by SeriesAddictSite

The Grinder

Fox’s comedy lineup and scheduling challenges may have contributed to the show’s underperformance in viewership. Rob Lowe as Dean Sanderson, plays a lawyer on TV and then tries to practice law in real life, alongside Fred Savage and Mary Elizabeth Ellis.

The Grinder by FOX 13 Tampa Bay

The Grinder (Cont.)

Fred Savage co-starred as Dean's long-suffering sibling, creating comedy gold through their opposite personalities and approaches to law. It's amazing how the show earned comparisons to Arrested Development and Better Off Ted, receiving excellent critical reviews and a complete 22-episode order.

The Grinder by FOX 13 Tampa Bay

Firefly

Joss Whedon's space western Firefly aired for 11 episodes in 2002, but its impact on science fiction television cannot be overstated. Set 500 years in the future, the series followed Captain Malcolm Reynolds and his ragtag crew aboard the transport ship Serenity, highlighting futuristic technology.

Firefly Season 1 digital trailer by sliver streets

Firefly (Cont.)

Nathan Fillion's portrayal of Reynolds anchored an ensemble cast that included Gina Torres, Alan Tudyk, and Summer Glau. The channel’s decision to cancel the series mid-season was so upsetting that it inspired a successful 2005 film, Serenity, which provided closure to the story.

Firefly Season 1 digital trailer by sliver streets

Dig

Jerusalem became the backdrop for an apocalyptic conspiracy thriller when Dig premiered on USA Network in 2015. It was developed by Tyrant co-creator Gideon Raff and Heroes creator Tim Kring. Jason Isaacs took over as FBI Special Agent Peter Connelly, investigating an American murder.

DIG Official Music Video Trailer #1 (2015) - Jason Isaacs TV Show HD by Rotten Tomatoes Trailers

Dig (Cont.)

The show was groundbreaking as the first major television production to film extensively in Jerusalem. In spite of expanding from six to ten episodes in its first season, low ratings prevented a second season, though Isaacs felt the plot worked well as a standalone miniseries.

DIG Official Music Video Trailer #1 (2015) - Jason Isaacs TV Show HD by Rotten Tomatoes Trailers

Red Band Society

Who would've thought a show about terminally ill teenagers in a hospital could be funny, energetic, and genuinely delightful? Red Band Society, produced by Steven Spielberg's Amblin Television, proved exactly that during its brief 2014–2015 run. Its cast included Octavia Spencer and Dave Annable.

Red Band Society Season 1 Episode 2 to 5 by Start Entertainment

Red Band Society (Cont.)

The self-titled Red Band Society united sick kids who supported each other through their medical struggles, with doctors and nurses forming their extended family. The young cast's emphatic rendition of "You Can't Always Get What You Want" in the last episode was a beautiful tribute to resilience.

Red Band Society Season 1 Episode 2 to 5 by Start Entertainment

Police Squad!

Leslie Nielsen's deadpan comedy genius reached its television peak in Police Squad!, a brilliant spoof of police procedurals that lasted around six episodes. Created by the same team behind Airplane!, it showcased Nielsen as Detective Frank Drebin, delivering absurdist humor with complete straight-faced sincerity.

Police Squad! (1982) - Episode 4: Club Flamingo Scene (HD) by Via Vision Entertainment

Police Squad! (Cont.)

Each episode packed more visual gags, wordplay, and surreal moments than most comedies managed in their entire seasons. These included Nielsen's oblivious interactions with obvious criminals as well as the show's running joke of freeze-frame endings. ABC executives famously canceled it claiming viewers had to “think too much”.

Police Squad! (1982) - Episode 4: Club Flamingo Scene (HD) by Via Vision Entertainment

Continuum

Rachel Nichols starred as Kiera Cameron, a future cop accidentally transported from 2077 back to 2012 when chasing terrorists called Liber8 in this Canadian sci-fi masterpiece. Continuum ran for four seasons and 42 episodes (2012–2015), yet never achieved the recognition it deserved for its plot.

Continuum - 3 Minute Sneak Peek | Showcase Canada by Showcase Network

Continuum (Cont.)

Creator Simon Berry crafted a complex narrative exploring how social media, technology, and corporate power shape society's future while examining the butterfly effect of changing the past. The fourth season was shortened to six episodes, forcing the creators to condense storylines and cut planned arcs.

Continuum - 3 Minute Sneak Peek | Showcase Canada by Showcase Network

Breaking In

Fox's mid-season replacement strategy struck comedy gold with Breaking In, a sitcom that piggybacked on American Idol's audience in 2011. Sadly, the show lost half its audience by episode seven, leading to initial cancellation, brief renewal, and final removal.

Breaking In - Official Trailer [HD] by Universal Pictures

Breaking In (Cont.)

Created by The Goldbergs maestro Adam Goldberg, the series centered on employees at Contra Security, a firm that tested clients' security by breaking into their homes. Christian Slater brought his signature intensity to Oz Osbourne, the company's sporadic leader throughout the first season. 

Breaking In - Official Trailer [HD] by Universal Pictures

The Tick

Ben Edlund's beloved blue superhero has enjoyed multiple television adaptations, but none captured the comic's satirical brilliance quite like the original live-action series. Patrick Warburton personified the childlike, invulnerable Tick alongside David Burke's neurotic Arthur in this comedy that balanced superhero parody with sophisticated humor.

The Tick - Official Trailer by IGN

The Tick (Cont.)

Amazon’s decision to scrap it was influenced by the competitive streaming market and the need to allocate resources to bigger hits like The Boys. Creator Ben Edlund's attempts to find a new platform for a third season were also unsuccessful before actor contracts expired.

The Tick - Official Trailer by IGN

Krypton

Superman's grandfather took center stage in this ambitious prequel series, Krypton. It changed what could have been simple nostalgia into compelling science fiction. Cameron Cuffe acted as Seg-El, fighting to save his planet while unknowingly ensuring his grandson's future existence through time-travel storylines.

KRYPTON (Syfy) Trailer HD - Superman prequel series by TV Promos

Krypton (Cont.)

The show’s premise—set generations before Superman’s birth—meant it lacked familiar, iconic characters. This made it harder to attract mainstream DC fans. Unlike Smallville or the Arrowverse, Krypton didn’t benefit from direct connections to other popular DC properties. 

KRYPTON (Syfy) Trailer HD - Superman prequel series by TV Promos

Wonderfalls

Here, we meet a disaffected Niagara Falls gift shop employee whose life changes when inanimate objects begin speaking to her. Created by Bryan Fuller and Todd Holland, the show mixed supernatural elements with sharp wit, underlining themes of destiny, purpose, and reluctant heroism through beautifully crafted episodes.

Wonderfalls (2004) - Episode 7 of 13 - 4K AI Remaster by Owen Davies

Wonderfalls (Cont.)

The talking objects, such as wax lions and mounted fish, guided Jaye toward helping strangers in ways that initially seemed random but revealed deeper patterns. Only four of the thirteen produced episodes were broadcast, though the complete series later found devoted fans on DVD.

Wonderfalls (2004) - Episode 7 of 13 - 4K AI Remaster by Owen Davies

Freaks And Geeks

As per reports, Freaks and Geeks faced tough competition from non-scripted series such as Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Besides, the network's erratic scheduling, marked by inconsistent air dates and lengthy gaps between episodes, further undermined its potential to build a consistent audience.

FREAKS AND GEEKS | Now On Digital | Paramount Movies by Paramount Movies

Freaks And Geeks (Cont.)

Linda Cardellini was seen as Lindsay Weir, a mathlete who began hanging with burnouts, while her younger brother overcame his social struggles. The series launched the careers of numerous comedic talents. These included Seth Rogen, Jason Segel, James Franco, Linda Cardellini, and Busy Philipps.

FREAKS AND GEEKS | Now On Digital | Paramount Movies by Paramount Movies

Marco Polo

Netflix's lavish historical epic Marco Polo premiered in 2014 as one of the streaming giant's most ambitious early projects, rivaling Game of Thrones in scope and production value. It is Lorenzo Richelmy and Benedict Wong who brought the Mongol Empire to life with epic battle sequences.

Marco Polo | official trailer (2014) Netflix by moviemaniacsDE

Marco Polo (Cont.)

This was one of television's most expensive productions at the time, with each episode costing millions to create authentic period costumes, sets, and locations. Due to a staggering $200 million loss, Marco Polo became Netflix’s first original series to be scrapped before a third season.

Marco Polo | official trailer (2014) Netflix by moviemaniacsDE

Damnation

Tony Tost's Depression-era Western Damnation arrived on USA Network in 2017. The show tackled America's violent labor wars with unflinching intensity, touching upon themes of class struggle and economic inequality. James Mangold helped develop a powerful narrative about workers fighting corporate oppression.

Damnation USA Network Trailer #4 by TV Promo 360

Damnation (Cont.)

Well, the USA's demographics didn't really accept the heavy subject matter, leading to cancellation after one season. Netflix also streamed the gritty 1930s period drama internationally but was forced to remove it from its platform in 2023, further limiting its accessibility. 

Damnation USA Network Trailer #4 by TV Promo 360

The Exorcist

Fox's bold continuation of the 1973 horror classic came out in 2016, ignoring all previous sequels to deliver a worthy successor decades later. Alfonso Herrera and Ben Daniels depicted Father Tomas Ortega and Father Marcus Keane, dual priests confronting demonic forces in this thriller.

The Exorcist | official trailer (2016) by moviemaniacsDE

The Exorcist (Cont.)

Psychological horror was balanced with genuine character development across two 10-episode seasons. Airing on Fridays and facing competition from other programming contributed to its poor ratings. Both seasons are currently available on streaming platforms like Hulu, Amazon Prime Video, and Apple TV.

The Exorcist | official trailer (2016) by moviemaniacsDE

Almost Human

Karl Urban and Michael Ealy formed television's most compelling human-android partnership set in 2048. By the season finale, Kennex and Dorian had evolved from reluctant partners to genuine friends, but audiences didn't follow their journey, leading to cancellation after a severe viewership decline.

Almost Human - Series Trailer by GianniGuy

Almost Human (Cont.)

Anyway, the show’s premise of a human detective partnered with an android offers a fresh take on crime dramas and sci-fi. You get to witness intriguing world-building about a technologically advanced but socially complex future. Supporting characters like MacKenzie Crook’s Rudy add humor and dimension.

Almost Human - Series Trailer by GianniGuy