Steve v. Dean
Steve Perry didn’t just sing for Journey—he defined them. His soaring tenor helped turn arena rock into emotional spectacle, and his voice became one of the most recognizable in music. But decades later, another musician inside the band sparked a new debate: what if Journey’s most powerful voice didn’t belong to their frontman… but their drummer?
Perry Earned “The Voice” For a Reason
Before any comparisons, credit where it’s due: Perry’s voice was a once-in-a-generation instrument. His tone was pure, his vibrato was flawless, and his emotional control was unmatched. Jon Bon Jovi is widely credited with giving Perry his nickname—he called him “The Voice” repeatedly in interviews throughout the ’80s and ’90s.
He Redefined What Arena Rock Could Sound Like
Songs like Open Arms, Lights, and Who’s Crying Now showcased a vocal power that few singers could even attempt. Perry could cut through stadiums without losing warmth, becoming the blueprint for countless rock vocalists who followed.
Ebet Roberts/Redferns, Getty Images
His Bandmates Knew They’d Found Lightning in a Bottle
Neal Schon has called Perry “one of a kind,” and Jonathan Cain said Perry’s voice “could move mountains.” Inside Journey, there was never any confusion—Perry was the engine of their sound. But the band also had deeper vocal chops than most fans ever realized.
Travis Shinn, Wikimedia Commons
Journey Quietly Built a Band Full of Strong Singers
Even in the Perry era, Journey was secretly a multi-vocalist band. Gregg Rolie, Neal Schon, Jonathan Cain, and Ross Valory all contributed harmonies that thickened the band’s signature sound. Songs like Feeling That Way and Anytime prove Journey was never a one-voice operation.
Matt Becker, Wikimedia Commons
Which Sets Up the Twist: Enter Deen Castronovo
By the time drummer Deen Castronovo joined in 1998, Perry was long gone—but the band’s tradition of powerful singers wasn’t. Fans knew Deen as a monster drummer from Bad English and other projects. What they didn’t know was that he had one of the most astonishing voices in modern rock.
The First Time Fans Heard Him Sing, Everything Changed
During early 2000s tours, Castronovo stepped up to the mic for backups—and instantly stunned audiences. His tone was shockingly clean, his pitch laser-accurate, and his delivery eerily reminiscent of Perry. Word spread fast: Journey’s drummer could sing.
Dave Golland, Wikimedia Commons
Neal Schon Publicly Confirmed What Fans Were Hearing
Schon didn’t mince words. He said Castronovo had “the closest voice to Steve” he had ever heard. Coming from someone who spent years beside Perry, that wasn’t casual praise—it was a stamped and sealed endorsement. Suddenly, the debate wasn’t fringe anymore.
Robert Knight, Wikimedia Commons
Castronovo Didn’t Sound Like a Perry Impression—He Just Sang Like That
Some singers imitate. Deen didn’t. His natural tone carried the same soaring purity Perry was known for, which is why fans often did a double-take when hearing him live. The similarity wasn’t forced—it was simply how his voice worked.
Tommy-Orange, Wikimedia Commons
His Emotional Delivery Matched the Original Spirit of the Songs
Perry’s magic wasn’t just technical—it was emotional. And to many fans’ surprise, Castronovo brought the same cracked-open vulnerability to songs like Faithfully and Mother, Father. He wasn’t just hitting notes—he was feeling them.
His Version of “Mother, Father” Became a Fan-Favorite Moment
Of all the songs in Journey’s catalog, Mother, Father might be the toughest vocally. Deen’s live versions became legendary—some fans even prefer them to the original. YouTube comments became a chorus of: “How is the drummer singing like THIS?”
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
He Could Sing Perry-Level High Notes While Drumming
Hitting Steve Perry–style notes is brutally hard. Doing it while playing drums is almost unheard of. Castronovo is one of the rare rock musicians—alongside someone like Phil Collins—who can perform at that level. It made his performances even more jaw-dropping.
At Times, He Hit Notes Perry Avoided Live in Later Years
As Perry moved away from touring and the songs changed live, some of the highest peaks were softened to preserve vocal health. Castronovo, decades later, was still belting those same lines cleanly, fueling the “better voice?” debate even more.
His Tone Had Perry’s Purity With Extra Rock Grit
Castronovo wasn’t a clone. His voice carried Perry’s clarity but added a modern rasp that gave old songs new punch. It felt like hearing classic Journey with a slightly harder edge—respectful, but with fresh electricity.
Fans Began Debating the Real “Voice of Journey”
As clips circulated online, fans started arguing: Was Perry the more iconic voice… or was Castronovo the technically stronger singer? Journey forums lit up with debates, and critics joined in too. As Classic Rock Magazine noted, “Castronovo’s voice is so close to Steve Perry’s it can be startling.”
Even Perry Loyalists Admitted Deen’s Talent Was Unavoidable
Hardcore Perry defenders—people who treat Frontiers like scripture—still gave Castronovo credit. One popular comment: “Perry will always be #1. But Deen? Man… he’s right there.”
Journey Let Deen Take Full Lead Vocals for a Reason
The band didn’t just use him for backups. They let him front entire songs on tour. His leads on Faithfully, Mother, Father, and Open Arms weren’t novelties—they were highlights. The band knew they had a rare dual-threat talent.
His Return to Journey Showed His Voice Hadn’t Faded
After personal struggles briefly removed him from the lineup, Castronovo rejoined in 2021. Within minutes of hearing him, fans realized nothing had changed—those pipes were still pristine.
His Duets With Arnel Pineda Highlighted His Flexibility Even More
In recent years, Castronovo and Pineda have shared vocal duties in a way few bands can pull off. Their harmonies and traded lines only reinforced how naturally elite Deen’s voice is. As Pineda himself said, “Deen can sing anything. He’s amazing.”
So…Was Deen Castronovo Actually the Best Singer in Journey?
It depends on what “best” means. Perry was the original—the icon, the emotional anchor, the voice that sold millions. Castronovo was the shock—the drummer who could match (and sometimes surpass) Perry’s technique. Two different kinds of greatness.
Maybe the Real Answer Is Simple: Journey Had Two Voices Worthy of the Name
Perry created the sound. Castronovo proved it could live on at the highest level. And together, across different eras, they show why Journey remains one of the most vocally gifted rock bands of all time.
You Might Also Like:
The Most Perfect Basslines In Rock And Roll History Will Be Stuck In Our Heads Forever
