Cut It Out? These Songs Almost Didn’t Make The Album
They’re classics now—but they almost didn’t make the cut. Whether due to studio pressure, band infighting, or sheer bad timing, these iconic tracks were nearly dropped from the albums that made them famous. Thankfully, someone spoke up, and music fans everywhere are still listening.
Here are 20 legendary songs that were "this close" to maybe being lost forever.
"Billie Jean" (Michael Jackson)
Producer Quincy Jones reportedly thought Billie Jean had too long an intro and wasn’t strong enough. He even suggested shortening it and renaming it “Not My Lover.” Michael Jackson insisted on keeping the full 29-second intro, saying it was what made him want to dance—so the rest of the team relented.
Michael Jackson - Billie Jean (Official Video), Michael Jackson
"Smells Like Teen Spirit" (Nirvana)
Smells Like Teen Spirit was nearly cut from Nevermind. The band felt it sounded too much like the Pixies and were hesitant about its polished sound. Producer Butch Vig encouraged them to finish it. When it dropped, it set off a musical revolution and became grunge’s defining anthem.
Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit (Official Music Video), Nirvana
"Like a Rolling Stone" (Bob Dylan)
At over six minutes, Like a Rolling Stone was seen as too long for radio. Dylan nearly tossed the lyrics and shelved the song. But producer Tom Wilson persuaded him to finish it. The track redefined what a single could be—and helped launch Dylan into rock stardom.
Bob Dylan - Like A Rolling Stone (Live at Newport 1965), Monotone
"Losing My Religion" (R.E.M.)
When R.E.M. brought Losing My Religion to the table, their label wasn’t sure a mandolin-led track would resonate. Michael Stipe also doubted its abstract lyrics. Producer Scott Litt pushed for it—and the song became the band’s biggest U.S. hit, ushering in a new era of alternative rock.
R.E.M. - Losing My Religion (Official HD Music Video), remhq
"Creep" (Radiohead)
Radiohead nearly dropped Creep from Pablo Honey. Thom Yorke wasn’t sure about the lyrics, and the band even tried to sabotage it in the studio. But their label believed in the song. It launched Radiohead’s career—even as the band later tried to distance themselves from it.
"Bohemian Rhapsody" (Queen)
Bohemian Rhapsody was nearly left off A Night at the Opera. EMI thought it was too long, too weird, and radio-hostile. Queen insisted on keeping it intact, and a DJ’s rogue airplay gave it life. It went on to become one of the most celebrated songs in rock history.
Queen – Bohemian Rhapsody (Official Video Remastered), Queen Official
"Every Breath You Take" (The Police)
Every Breath You Take was nearly dismissed for being too soft and repetitive. Even within The Police, there were disagreements. But Sting pushed to include it on Synchronicity. It became their biggest hit and one of the most played songs in radio history.
The Police - Every Breath You Take (Official Music Video), The Police
"Wonderwall" (Oasis)
Wonderwall almost didn’t make it onto (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? due to tension over who would sing it. Liam and Noel Gallagher clashed—and for a moment, the song was on the chopping block. But it stayed, and went on to become the anthem of a generation.
Oasis - Wonderwall (Official Video), Oasis
"Good Vibrations" (The Beach Boys)
Good Vibrations was expensive, complex, and time-consuming to record. Brian Wilson’s vision pushed the limits of ’60s production, and Capitol Records wasn’t sure it was worth the trouble. But he stood firm, and the song became a psychedelic pop masterpiece (and a number-one hit).
The Beach Boys - Good Vibrations (Official Music Video), The Beach Boys
"Black Dog" (Led Zeppelin)
Black Dog almost didn’t make Led Zeppelin IV. The song’s irregular time signature and unusual structure raised eyebrows within the band. But its power couldn’t be denied, and it became a fan favorite and classic rock staple.
Led Zeppelin - Black Dog (Live at Madison Square Garden 1973) (Official Video), Led Zeppelin
"November Rain" (Guns N’ Roses)
Axl Rose had worked on November Rain for years before it finally appeared on Use Your Illusion I. Its nine-minute orchestral sprawl worried the band and the label. But Rose pushed for it—and the song became a chart-topping power ballad with one of the most iconic music videos of the ’90s.
Guns N' Roses - November Rain, Guns N' Roses
"Hurt" (Nine Inch Nails)
Trent Reznor feared Hurt was too personal and slow for The Downward Spiral. It was nearly cut from the tracklist. Instead, it became the album’s haunting closer—later famously covered by Johnny Cash, giving the song renewed emotional power.
Nine Inch Nails - Hurt (VEVO Presents), Nine Inch Nails
"Double Life" (The Cars)
Double Life was almost left off Candy-O after internal band debate. Ric Ocasek later confirmed the song had lost a vote but was ultimately added to the album. Its moody tone and rhythmic drive made it a cult favorite among fans.
The Cars - Double Life, stereomusicvideo
"The Boys Are Back in Town" (Thin Lizzy)
It’s hard to imagine Jailbreak without The Boys Are Back in Town—but the band and label nearly left it off. Management pushed for its inclusion, and the song became a massive hit and Thin Lizzy’s signature track.
Thin Lizzy - The Boys Are Back In Town (Official Music Video), Thin Lizzy Official
"Fast Car" (Tracy Chapman)
Fast Car was initially seen as too slow and too introspective to be a hit. Elektra considered leaving it off the album until Chapman performed it live at a Mandela tribute concert. Radio picked it up soon after—and it became a timeless classic.
Tracy Chapman - Fast Car (Official Music Video), Tracy Chapman
"Stayin’ Alive" (Bee Gees)
Stayin’ Alive was a late addition to Saturday Night Fever. The Bee Gees and producers questioned whether it fit the soundtrack. But when it hit the airwaves, it transformed the group into disco icons.
Bee Gees - Stayin' Alive (Official Music Video), beegees
"Fly Away" (Lenny Kravitz)
Lenny Kravitz didn’t originally plan to include Fly Away on 5. It was a last-minute track, and the label initially passed on it. After Kravitz sent it again, they reconsidered. It won him a Grammy and became his biggest hit.
Lenny Kravitz - Fly Away (Official Music Video), Lenny Kravitz
"Seven Nation Army" (The White Stripes)
Jack White almost left Seven Nation Army off Elephant. He thought the riff was too simple. But it made the cut—and that simple riff became one of the most recognizable in rock history.
The White Stripes - Seven Nation Army (Official Music Video), The White Stripes
"Sweet Dreams" (Eurythmics)
When Annie Lennox and Dave Stewart presented Sweet Dreams to their label, it was rejected for being too cold and synthetic. But a DJ played it anyway, and it exploded. The song launched Eurythmics into global stardom.
"I Remember You" (Skid Row)
Skid Row originally treated I Remember You as a writing exercise, not planning to record it. Fans kept requesting it at shows—so the band changed their mind. It became their signature ballad and a staple of ’80s rock radio.
Skid Row - I Remember You (Official Music Video), RHINO
You Might Also Like:
Country Hits That We Should Really Stop Singing, But We Can't
Once Popular Bands That Are Now Totally Forgotten
