Shocking Stories From The Set Of Gilligan's Island

Shocking Stories From The Set Of Gilligan's Island


June 24, 2025 | Jillian Kent

Shocking Stories From The Set Of Gilligan's Island


The Gang’s All Here

Gilligan’s Island ran for three seasons in the mid-60s. It was a comedic masterpiece filled with memorable characters. 50 years later, people are still interested in Gilligan’s Island, so here is the story behind the hit show.

Gilligan-Msn

Bob Denver & The Lion

Gilligan’s Island was filled with zany antics that often put the characters in some form of danger. After all, they were all stranded on an island. Of course, the danger was only to the characters, not the cast—or was it?

File:Bob Denver Gilligans Island 1966.jpgCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Bob Denver & The Lion

At one point, the show featured a story in which Gilligan (played by Bob Denver) was trapped in a hut with a lion. All perfectly safe, right? Well, maybe not as safe as you think.

Gilligan's IslandLocking Himself in a Hut with a Lion | Gilligan's Biggest Blunders, MeTV

Advertisement

Bob Denver & The Lion

Fellow actor Dawn Wells remarked that even the trainer seemed to have some trouble handling the lion. When filming the scene in which Gilligan noticed the lion, the lion decided to leap at Bob Denver instead!

File:Bob Denver Gilligans Island 1965.jpgCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Bob Denver & The Lion

Fortunately for Denver, the lion trainer was quick on his feet. He jumped into action, tackling the lion before it could get to Denver. Denver’s instinctual reaction—to start karate chopping—likely wouldn’t have been a match for the lion.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

Alan Hale Jr’s Little Secret

During the wrap party for the first season of the show, showrunner Sherwood Schwartz was in for a big surprise. Alan Hale Jr, who played skipper, made an offhand comment that gave Schwartz cause for some alarm.

File:Alan Hale Jr. Gilligans Island 1966.JPGCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Alan Hale Jr’s Little Secret

Hale told Schwartz that the wrapping of the season finally gave him a much-needed opportunity. Now that they were no longer filming, Hale remarked that he finally had a chance to let his arm heal.

Gilligan's Island Gilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

Alan Hale Jr’s Little Secret

This being the first time he’d heard anything about Hale’s arm, Schwartz was understandably confused. When Schwartz asked what Hale meant, Hale was far too casual for what the situation called for.

File:Sherwood Schwartz Star Ceremony.jpgNicolj, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Alan Hale Jr’s Little Secret

Three weeks earlier, Hale had missed a safety pad when falling out of a tree. He’d broken his arm. However, he didn’t want to miss filming, so he didn’t tell anyone. Hale spent those three weeks lifting bags of coconuts, and even Bob Denver, all with a broken arm!

File:Alan Hale, Jr. 1959.jpgWarner Bros. Studio, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Delayed By History

Gilligan’s Island almost didn’t happen at all. They filmed their pilot in Hawaii; however, their plans to film at a local naval base became significantly delayed—for good reason.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

Delayed By History

They filmed in late 1963 and were scheduled to film at the naval base in mid-November. To be exact, they were meant to film there on November 23, 1963.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island Pilot (Marooned) Opening Theme and Closing, Mark Brown

Advertisement

Delayed By History

Any history buff can tell you that President John F Kennedy passed the day before. As a result, the government closed the base. Gilligan’s Island didn’t manage to return to finish their filming there until December.

File:John F. Kennedy speaks at Rice University.jpgUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Tina Louise Was Trouble

As much as you like to think that the stars of your favorite shows all become one big happy family, that isn’t always the case. Gilligan’s Island had one actress who couldn’t get along with the rest of the gang.

File:Hans Conried Tina Louise Gilligan's Island 1966.jpgCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Tina Louise Was Trouble

Tina Louise, who played movie star Ginger, might not have needed to dig too deep for inspiration. Supposedly, she got into arguments with her co-stars often. This seems to have started early on.

File:Tina Louise 1964.JPGCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Tina Louise Was Trouble

In 1965 TV Guide reported that Louise sat by herself between takes while the rest of her co-stars joked and got along. Decades later, when the opportunity to do reunion movies arose, Louise refused to reprise her role.

Tina Louise5 Ginger Moments!!--Gilligan's Island--Ginger Grant (Tina Louise), Rick Nineg

Advertisement

Somebody Save Them!

Most people understood that they were enjoying a comedy show. However, the concept of fiction did not quite dawn on all audience members watching Gilligan’s Island at the start.

Gilligan's IslandThe Professor Builds a Telephone to Call for Help - Gilligan's Island - 1966, Shatner Method

Advertisement

Somebody Save Them!

Sherwood Schwartz received the surprise of a lifetime early on in the show’s run. He received word from the US Coast Guard looking to check in on the status of his actors!

File:Seal of the United States Coast Guard.svgU.S. Government, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Somebody Save Them!

It seemed that some concerned viewers did not quite understand that no one was truly lost. The Coast Guard began receiving telegrams from people asking them to “rescue these poor people…”

 Gilligan's IslandGilligan's best moments, Frozen Gas

Advertisement

Jim Backus Didn’t Pay!

Despite playing a millionaire on the show—and likely receiving a healthy paycheck for his time—actor Jim Backus had a problem with spending his money. It seems that he was quite cheap.

Jim BackusGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

Jim Backus Didn’t Pay!

Backus, reportedly, would take his co-stars Dawn Wells and Natalie Schafer out for lunch regularly. However, when it came time to pay, remarkably, his wallet was always missing. Don’t worry, Wells and Schafer had the last laugh.

File:Dawn Wells Gilligan's Island 1964.jpgCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Jim Backus Didn’t Pay!

Although the ladies often paid for the meals (how could they not?), they didn’t let the matter slide. At some point after all was said and done, Schafer decided to get what she was owed. She gave Backus a bill for $300—what all those lunches supposedly came to. However, she didn’t need the money.

File:NatalieSchafer.jpgStudio Publicity, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Schafer Had Millions

Natalie Schafer played Jim Backus’s wife on the show. This meant that her character was also quite well off. However, Schafer could easily relate to her character: she, too, had plenty of money!

Natalie Schafer and Jim BackusGilligan's Island: The Best Of Mr. And Mrs. Howell - The Millionaire and his Wife! 🎵, Gilligan's Island

Advertisement

Schafer Had Millions

Schafer and her husband made some smart investments long before Gilligan’s Island even started. They invested in Beverly Hills real estate before the value began to rise. They were millionaires in their own right.

File:Natalie Schafer & Louis Calhern 1933.jpgLos Angeles Times, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Schafer Had Millions

If she was so well off, then why did she bother with the show at all? Well, Schafer once said that she just wanted a free trip to Hawaii. She was joking—probably.

Natalie SchaferGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

It Was Almost Very Different

Today, the cast of Gilligan’s Island is iconic. The characters are memorable and no one could think of them played by any other people. However, when it was first filmed, their cast was almost entirely different.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island - Mary Ann and Gilligan acting married, A Fan Editor

Advertisement

It Was Almost Very Different

In the first pilot, they filmed different actors playing the characters of the Professor and Ginger. It also included a character named “Bunny”. Unfortunately, that show didn’t work.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

It Was Almost Very Different

When showed that pilot, the executives at CBS were far from impressed. Unwilling to give up on the program, they fired the three actors mentioned above and changed “Bunny” to the character of Mary Ann.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

What About Jerry Van Dyke?

It was not just the previously mentioned roles that could have been quite different. Initially, the role of Gilligan was offered to Jerry Van Dyke. Van Dyke, however, had some strong opinions.

Jerry Van DykeJerry Van Dyke, comedian and actor, dies at 86, ABC30 Action News

Advertisement

What About Jerry Van Dyke?

Jerry Van Dyke didn’t think that Gilligan’s Island was marketable. He thought it would never be successful, so he took the lead in My Mother the Car—which has been called the worst television show of all time. Looks like giving up on Gilligan wasn’t the best move after all.

Jerry Van DykeJerry V. Dyke & My Mother the Car - Pilot, OLDSHOWS506070

Advertisement

Looking For The Skipper

The Skipper was another character that took a while for them to cast. Carroll O’Connor was considered for the role. Unfortunately, he couldn’t pull off what they were looking for in the auditions and Alan Hale Jr got the role.

File:Carrol O'Connor as Archie Bunker.JPGCBS Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Paying For The Reruns

When Gilligan’s Island first aired, television was still fairly fresh. No one was thinking about reruns. Unlike today, none of the actors had residuals written into their contracts. However, one might have gotten around that.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island - Professor & Gilligan Scenes, Gilligan's Island

Advertisement

Paying For The Reruns

The rumor goes that Dawn Wells and her agent (who was her husband) reached out to CBS asking to be paid for the reruns and the lawyers didn’t fight her on it. However, Wells has a different story.

File:Dawn Wells with memories.jpgJohn Mathew Smith & www.celebrity-photos.com, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Paying For The Reruns

While it is a nice story, it’s unlikely to be true. Dawn Wells herself has gone on record saying that “We didn’t really get a dime” for any reruns that were aired.

File:Dawn Wells 1975.jpgFreeman and Best?, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

What’s Gilligan’s First Name?

Pay attention to this one as it’s a very popular trivia question. It’s also a difficult one to answer as there are a couple of possibilities that exist.

Bob DenverGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

What’s Gilligan’s First Name?

Sherwood Schwartz has said that he considered “Willy” as a first name for the title character. Thanks to this, the name even appeared on an early press release. However, as time went on, Schwartz seemed to change his mind.

Bob DenverGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

What’s Gilligan’s First Name?

Later, after the show had been on for some time, Schwartz made a different statement. He stated that the Howells are the only characters on the show who are addressed by their last names. What does this mean for Gilligan?

Gilligan's IslandA Gilligan's Island Halloween, Chief Scheider

Advertisement

What’s Gilligan’s First Name?

Well, it means that Gilligan is his first name. It’s his last name that’s a mystery. Bob Denver has also said that Gilligan is the character’s first name. So, next time someone asks you at trivia, remember: it’s a trick question.

File:Bob Denver, 1977.jpgHaarFager at en.wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

You Can’t Escape The Fans!

Gilligan’s Island has fans all over the world. As a result, the actors often find themselves facing fans in the oddest of places. Russell Johnson (the Professor) found a room full of PhDs were huge fans and Dawn Wells found a fan on an isolated island without electricity or running water!

File:Russell Johnson Black Saddle 1960.JPGABC Television, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

It’s A Political Show

The idea for Gilligan’s Island started when Schwartz was in college. Each student in the class was asked to say what they’d bring to a desert island. The answers struck Schwartz and the idea stayed with him.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

It’s A Political Show

Schwartz’s initial idea was of a show that was a satirical and political comment on the silliness of people viewing each other all as “different” when survival depends on each other. Although Schwartz toned the idea down, you can still see these undertones in the show.

Bob DenverGilligan's Island | Gilligan's Best Moments | Compilation | Warner Classics, Warner Bros. Classics

Advertisement

And The Rest

The first season of Gilligan’s Island left a major part of their crew out of the credits. Mary Ann and the Professor aren’t mentioned in the opening credits. Instead, they are simply lumped together as “The Rest”.

Mary Ann and the ProfessorGilligan's Island - The Professor and Mary Ann's Screentime, Gilligan's Island

Advertisement

And The Rest

Bob Denver didn’t think that was right. He used his influence as the “star” of the show to get them the recognition they deserved. Denver’s intervention worked and Mary Ann and the Professor got proper recognition during season 2.

Professor and Mary AnnGilligan's Island - The Professor and Mary Ann's Screentime, Gilligan's Island

Advertisement

The Darker Side Of Gilligan

In 2003, writer Tom Carson felt that Gilligan’s Island didn’t go deep enough. He published a novel titled Gilligan’s Wake. The book is a collection of short stories with some interesting ideas about the show's characters.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island Bamboo Car, Chief Scheider

Advertisement

The Darker Side Of Gilligan

Gilligan’s Wake dives into the backstories of the characters and each one is darker than the next. Each character carries a secret that shows them to be not as wholesome as they initially appeared.

Gilligan's IslandGilligan's Island - Gilligan's WWII Mine, Ricki Stromm

You May Also Like:

Forgotten Hit Shows From The 1950s

Forgotten Shows From The Golden Age Of Television

The Real-Life Shenanigans Of Bob Denver, TV’s Most Lovable Goofball

Sources: 1, 2


READ MORE

Cassandra Peterson aka Elvira Portrait Session 1974
June 28, 2025 Alex Summers

Elvira: Behind The Mask Of A Horror Icon

Cassandra Peterson rose to fame for her horror hostess role of Elvira. Her real life was every bit as terrifying—and titillating—as the films she presented to audiences.
GettyImages-165084168 Portrait of Dirk Bogarde in a Pool
June 27, 2025 Sammy Tran

Dirk Bogarde’s Secret Double Life

Dirk Bogarde played countless roles on and off screen—but he kept just as many secrets, including one with the power to destroy his life.
American actress Ann Sheridan (1915 - 1967), circa 1940.
June 25, 2025 Miles Brucker

Hollywood’s “Oomph Girl” Hid A Wild Secret

In the vicious land of Hollywood, former pin-up girl Ann Sheridan desperately wanted to be taken seriously. She became a classic movie actress with a rebellious streak—but sadly, a career in the spotlight couldn’t promise her a “happily ever after”.
fb image
June 24, 2025 Miles Brucker

These Photos Show Life On The Set Of Classic American Westerns

Classic Hollywood Westerns continue to dazzle audiences with their rugged heroes and sweeping scenery. But what happened behind the camera often goes unnoticed and unappreciated.
Intro
June 24, 2025 Miles Brucker

You Probably Missed These Big Mistakes In Television's Most Loved Shows

Some of television's most revered episodes hide slips that survived every table read. The errors even slipped through final edits. Spotting them unearths the hectic reality behind polished drama and comedy.
1987 Actress Florence Henderson poses for a portrait in 1987 in Los Angeles, California.
June 24, 2025 Carl Wyndham

The Other Side Of The Brady Bunch’s “Perfect” Mother

Florence Henderson rose to fame as Carol Brady in the wholesome sitcom The Brady Bunch. But her perfect television family had dark secrets.