June 20, 2024 | Alex Summers

The Greatest Actresses Of All Time, According To The AFI


Screen Legends

When it comes to the history of film in the US, there’s no better authority than the American Film Institute. They looked at performers who began appearing in films no later than 1950 and who had a significant screen presence in American movies to make the list, and narrowed it down to a list of 25 actresses, down from 250.

In a ceremony hosted by Shirley Temple in 1999, they first announced their list of the greatest screen legends. Though most of them may be gone, thanks to their incredible work on screen, they’ll never be forgotten.

Ga Thumb 1

25. Ava Gardner

Though Gardner grew up down South on a tobacco farm, she was discovered when her brother-in-law used a photo he’d taken of her in his Manhattan photo studio. Though she had zero acting experience, she was gorgeous—and that’s what led MGM to recruit her, based solely on her photo.

Though she struggled to get noticed in Hollywood at first—imagine!—she eventually built a fruitful and long-lasting career for herself, appearing in films well into the 1980s.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Ava Gardner from her role in Show Boat.MGM, Wikimedia Commons

24. Mary Pickford

This Canadian sweetheart was one half of Hollywood’s original power couple with her husband Douglas Fairbanks. Pickford was a silent star with an angelic face—but thanks to her immense talent, she successfully made the transition to talkies. Pickford established so many firsts in Hollywood. She helped found the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, was the first actress to leave her hand and footprints outside of Grauman’s Chinese Theater, and was even the subject of the first close-up shot!

Mary Pickford, head-and-shoulders portrait, facing frontRufus Porter Moody, Wikimedia Commons

23. Carole Lombard

Lombard was a stunning beauty whose smoldering looks would’ve made her perfect as a film noir femme fatale—but she actually did her best work cracking jokes in screwball comedies. She was one half of a legendary on- and off-screen partnership with Clark Gable. The pair first met as extras on 1925's Ben-Hur, but took their time to finally get together and fall in love.

Sadly, their love story was tragically cut short by Lombard’s death in a plane crash in 1942.

Photo of Carole Lombard from the cover of the January 1940 issue of Photoplay magazinePaul Hesse, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

22. Jean Harlow

Jean Harlow was Hollywood’s original blonde bombshell, beginning her career in the most inconspicuous of ways—as a young housewife in Los Angeles, she decided to make some extra money working as an extra. After being discovered by Howard Hughes, she eventually became one of film’s biggest stars in the 1930s. Sadly, it was all over just as quickly as it began—at the age of 26, Harlow passed on from kidney failure.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Jean Harlow facing the camera.George Hurrell, Wikimedia Commons

21. Sophia Loren

The only living legend on this list, Sophia Loren has steamed up screens since 1950—when she was just 16 years old. After appearing in a handful of Italian films, Paramount Pictures smartly signed her for a five-picture deal in 1958—but it was ultimately another Italian film, legendary director Vittorio de Sica’s Two Women in 1960, that won her a Best Actress Oscar.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Sophia Loren smiling and facing the cameraPaul A. Hesse Studios, Wikimedia Commons

20. Lauren Bacall

Is there another star who defines the idea of an Old Hollywood screen siren better than Lauren Bacall? Bacall had femme fatale looks and an iconic deep voice that made her an unforgettable screen presence. When she was just 19, she was cast opposite Humphrey Bogart—marking the start of a fruitful on- and off-screen relationship.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Lauren Bacall in a black dress facing the cameraUnknown Author, Wikimedia Commons

19. Rita Hayworth

Born Margarita Carmen Cansino, Hayworth began her career as a dancer before she moved into acting. Her father was the ultimate stage parent. He hired a consultant to ensure that his daughter would get a studio contract, who recommended that she change her name to hide her Latin roots, change her hairline, and dye her hair red. His advice worked, and Hayworth became a star, often nicknamed the “Love Goddess” for her siren roles.

Original publicity portrait of Rita Hayworth from the film Down to EarthNed Scott, Wikimedia Commons

18. Shirley Temple

Shirley Temple was THE original child star in Old Hollywood. She got her first Oscar at age 6, and is still the youngest person ever to receive an Academy Award. Though she stopped appearing in films at the age of 21, she went on to have a fruitful career as a diplomat.

Shirley Temple in Mr. Belvedere Goes to College (1949)Unknown Author, Wikimedia Commons 

17. Lillian Gish

When it comes to screen legends who stood the test of time, no other actor or actress can compare to Lillian Gish, who had a career that spanned 75 years. Discovered by Mary Pickford, she became a silent screen staple, and in her first two years as an actress, she appeared in 25 films. Her first film was made in 1912, while her last was in 1987.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Actress Lillian Gish in a white dress and white hatBain News Service, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

16. Vivien Leigh

Is there an epic that better represents the Golden Age of Hollywood better than Gone With the Wind? Leigh beat out hundreds of hopeful actresses to get the part of Scarlett O’Hara, for which she won the Best Actress Oscar. Leigh was also incredibly choosy when it came to picking roles, appearing in fewer than 20 films—but undoubtedly giving a rousing performance in each.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of actress Vivien Leigh as Scarlet O'Hara.Fawcett Publications, Wikimedia Commons

15. Mae West

Many of the actresses on this list were prim, proper, and elegant not just in the roles they chose, but also in the image they projected off-screen. The same can’t be said about Mae West. She wasn’t just an actress—she was a provocateur. With a personality bigger than any screen she ever appeared on, West was born to be a star, and she left her mark in early work like She Done Him Wrong as much as she did with later films like Myra Breckinridge.

Mae West sitting in court during questioning about profits earned from her role in the movie She Done Him WrongLos Angeles Daily News, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

14. Ginger Rogers

In the 1930s, Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire dominated Hollywood with a string of nine hit musicals. She went on to win an Oscar for the film Kitty Foyle in 1940, and became one of the biggest box office draws throughout the 1940s in dramas and comedies. She appeared in 73 films over the span of her career.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Ginger Rogers in Tender Comrade, 1943Studio publicity still, Wikimedia Commons

13. Grace Kelly

No one embodied the Hollywood dream quite like Grace Kelly. The elegant star made her name in adventure and Western films before raking in the awards for dramas like The Country Girl. Three iconic Alfred Hitchcock thrillers followed before Kelly retired from acting at the age of 26 to marry Prince Rainier III of Monaco.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Grace Kelly in floral dress, facing the camera.Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Wikimedia Commons

12. Claudette Colbert

Colbert’s refined elegance and distinctive mid-Atlantic accent made her a huge box office draw in the 30s and 40s, earning her the Oscar for 1934’s It Happened One Night. She was so convinced that the award would go to Bette Davis that she refused to attend the ceremony, and was about to board a train when her win was announced. Instead, she was convinced to rush to the venue to accept the award.

Grayscale Promotional photograph of actress Claudette Colbert in a floral dressParamount Studio, Wikimedia Commons

11. Barbara Stanwyck

Stanwyck is often called “the Best Actress who never won an Oscar,” which is a shame—because her on-screen performances certainly speak for themselves. From comedy to film noir, she could do it all, and she was not only an inspiration to younger stars, but also a kind mentor to up-and-comers like Marilyn Monroe.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Barbara Stanwyck n a floral dress, facing the cameraUnknown Author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

10. Joan Crawford

Prickly. Peculiar. Box office poison. Joan Crawford was called a lot of things during her career—but no one could deny her towering talent. Crawford went from appearing as hardworking, scrappy girls in rags-to-riches stories during the Great Depression in her early career before suffering a horrible downturn. She made a comeback playing wild, tempestuous characters who seemed much truer to life in films like Mildred Pierce and Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?

Grayscale Portrait Publicity photo of Joan Crawford in a white floral dresGeorge Hurrell, Wikimedia Commons

9. Marlene Dietrich

Though Marlene Dietrich appeared to be an ice queen both on and off-screen, her stormy personal life says otherwise. Her success in German film got her attention in Hollywood. Paramount signed her—and her instant success in films like Morocco, Blonde Venus, and The Devil Is A Woman proved that they’d made the right choice.

Grayscale Portrait Publicity photo of Marlene Dietrich for Paramount PicturesParamount Pictures, Wikimedia Commons

8. Judy Garland

After a brief stint as a vaudeville act, singing with her sisters, Judy Garland signed to MGM as a teenager—and instantly became one of the biggest stars the studio had ever seen, appearing in iconic hits like Meet Me In St Louis and The Wizard of Oz. Though she continued to make hits, including A Star is Born, it’s likely she’d still mark high up on this list even if she’d only ever appeared in The Wizard of Oz.

Judy Garland The Harvey Girls Mgm Publicity StillEric Carpenter, Wikimedia Commons

7. Elizabeth Taylor

Taylor had a dominating presence on the screen as much as she did in the tabloids, making headlines for her stormy marriages to stars like Eddie Fisher (her best friend’s husband), and Richard Burton. Between passionate affairs, she left her mark on the screen in legendary films like Cleopatra and BUtterfield 8.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Elizabeth Taylor, Late 1950SMGM publicity still, Wikimedia Commons

6. Marilyn Monroe

No matter how many try to take the mantle, Marilyn Monroe remains the ultimate classic Hollywood story, equal parts glamorous and tragic. Sadly derided as nothing more than a blonde bombshell, Monroe was actually in possession of a true acting talent, apparent in comedies like Some Like It Hot as much as in dramas like The Misfits.

Although she only acted for about a decade, Monroe became incredibly famous—only to suddenly pass at just 36 years old.

A glamorous Marilyn Monroe in a red dressSam Shaw, Wikimedia Commons

5. Greta Garbo

Garbo’s icy cool demeanor and portrayals of tragic characters made her a Hollywood legend, and she was such a massive star that her transition from silent films to talkies was heralded with the headline “Garbo talks”! And then, just as quickly as it began, it was over. After retiring in 1941, Garbo refused to make a comeback, despite repeated pleas from Hollywood.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Greta Garbo from the 1935 film Anna Karenina.MGM, Wikimedia Commons  

Advertisement

4. Ingrid Bergman

Despite being Swedish, Ingrid Bergman could’ve been one of the first actresses to earn the moniker of being “America’s Sweetheart”. She was beloved for her performances in classics like Casablanca, and had the awards to prove it—but then, an affair with director Roberto Rossellini threatened everything she’d built. Bergman was virtually exiled for years after the public uproar over her relationship with Rossellini, but eventually made a comeback in the mid-50s.

Original press release publicity photo of Ingrid Bergman for film Gaslight (1944)MGM photographer, Wikimedia Commons

3. Audrey Hepburn

Charming, gamine, and a true survivor, Audrey Hepburn was the picture of sophistication—but she didn’t just rest on her laurels, and was tireless in her dedication to helping children, and spent many years working with UNICEF. Unforgettable turns in films like Roman Holiday and Breakfast at Tiffany’s have cemented her status as one of the greatest screen legends of her time.

Grayscale Photo of actress Audrey Hepburn, smiling, looking upwardsMGM, Wikimedia Commons

2. Bette Davis

Davis’ sizzling performances, often as unlikable characters, practically burned through the screen. She could do anything, from romantic comedy to historical drama to thriller. After a career as one of the most bankable stars in the 1930s, she was one of many stars labeled box office poison—but she turned that moniker on its head with a massive comeback in the 1950s in films like All About Eve and Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? opposite her longtime rival, Joan Crawford.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Bette Davis in a black and white dressAlexander Kahle, Wikimedia Commons

1. Katharine Hepburn

While other stars oozed feminine glamor, Katharine Hepburn didn’t need gowns or jewels to stand out. She had an easygoing, tomboyish charisma in real life, but when she was on screen, she could morph to fit any role. She won four Best Actress Oscars, a record (her first and last wins were 48 years apart!), and was nominated 12 times. With stats like that, it’s no wonder that the AFI put her at the top of their list of American screen legends.

Grayscale Studio publicity photograph of Katharine Hepburn.Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios, Wikimedia Commons


READ MORE

Dsthumb
September 6, 2024 Jamie Hayes

Fearless Facts About Donald Sutherland, The Unsung Actor

Donald Sutherland spent decades wowing audiences with his skill and bravery, so it doesn't make sense that throughout his career, he never won an Oscar. But there may be a startling reason why the academy snubbed him.
Janet Jackson Facts
September 6, 2024 Mehroo S.

Controversial Facts About Janet Jackson, The Icon In The Shadows

Who doesn’t know the Jacksons? Their family story is seriously messed up—yet somehow, Janet Jackson came out of it all as a superstar, and seems relatively untouched by the drama. Well, keyword, relatively. What was it like for her to step out from the shadows of her famous siblings and make a name for herself? And how has she managed to escape the Jackson curse?
Ththumb
September 6, 2024 J. Clarke

Unhappy Facts About Tony Hancock, The Haunted Comedian

Tony Hancock spent his entire career making people laugh. But when it came to his own life and its shockingly tragic end, it turned out he didn’t have much of anything to laugh about.
Photo Session In A Dressing Room During Live In Berlin
September 6, 2024 Byron Fast

Maddening Facts About Metallica, Thrash Icons

Metallica, the only band that has played on all seven continents, has a long history filled with tragedy, overindulgence, and making a lot of people really, really angry.
Christopher Plummer Facts
September 6, 2024 Byron Fast

Off-Key Facts About Christopher Plummer, The Secretly Scandalous Icon

Christopher Plummer would rather fans forget his most famous role as the stoic head of the Von Trapp family. That guy was a real bore compared to the real-life Christopher Plummer: A self-proclaimed boozer and serial womanizer. If anyone thought Plummer was the male version of his saintly co-star Julie Andrews, here are some facts that’ll prove them wrong.
Wcthumb
September 6, 2024 Byron Fast

Sloppy Facts About WC Fields, Hollywood’s Tipsy Comic Genius

WC Fields was a sloshed-out comic genius who couldn't help but take his work home with him—and suffered the grim consequences because of it.