Child Actors Who Should Have Won The Oscar But Lost

Child Actors Who Should Have Won The Oscar But Lost


September 22, 2025 | Alex Summers

Child Actors Who Should Have Won The Oscar But Lost


Young Stars, Big Performances

Age is just a number when you’ve got talent that outshines the entire adult cast. Over the years, child actors have delivered performances so powerful, so magnetic, they’ve turned several projects into Oscar-worthy releases.

Intro

Advertisement

Haley Joel Osment – The Sixth Sense

The Academy gave Supporting Actor to Michael Caine in 1999, though Haley Joel Osment’s ghost-seeing child became a cultural landmark. At just 11, Osment balanced terror with innocence so powerfully that his “I see dead people” line is still quoted today. 

Screenshot from The Sixth Sense (1999)Buena Vista Pictures, The Sixth Sense (1999)

Advertisement

Quvenzhane Wallis – Beasts Of The Southern Wild

Before her 10th birthday, Quvenzhane Wallis stunned critics with raw, untrained brilliance in Beasts of the Southern Wild. She played Hushpuppy, a child facing ecological disaster and personal loss. Though Wallis made history as the youngest Best Actress nominee, the award slipped away.

Screenshot from Beasts of the Southern Wild (2012)Fox Searchlight Pictures, Beasts of the Southern Wild (2012)

Advertisement

Jacob Tremblay – Room

An 8-year-old Jacob Tremblay acted opposite Brie Larson in Room, holding his own against an eventual Oscar winner. His portrayal of a boy born in captivity discovering freedom for the first time felt heartbreakingly authentic. However, Larson’s victory overshadowed Tremblay’s remarkable achievement.

Screenshot from Room (2015)A24, Room (2015)

Advertisement

Brooklynn Prince – The Florida Project

Despite universal praise, Brooklynn Prince wasn’t nominated, which left many stunned at the oversight. Critics called Prince’s motel-dwelling child one of the finest performances of 2017. She was only 7, yet captured both the joy of play and the sting of poverty. 

Screenshot from The Florida Project (2017)A24, The Florida Project (2017)

Advertisement

Noah Jupe  Honey Boy

At 14, Noah Jupe reenacted Shia LaBeouf’s traumatic childhood in Honey Boy, exposing the toll of abusive parenting. His vulnerability shocked audiences and critics with unusual maturity for someone his age. Jupe’s performance stood among the year’s best, though Oscar voters ignored him.

 Screenshot from Honey Boy (2019)A24, The Florida Project (2017)

Advertisement

Jodie Foster – Taxi Driver

The Academy nominated Jodie Foster at 14, but even that didn’t feel like enough. She played Iris, a 12-year-old trapped in New York’s darkest corners, and never flinched. Foster’s silences carried more weight than most adult performances that year—including the winners.

 Screenshot from Taxi Driver (1976)Columbia Pictures, Taxi Driver (1976)

Advertisement

Abigail Breslin – Little Miss Sunshine

Abigail Breslin’s performance as Olive made people laugh, then made them completely uncomfortable—and that’s why it worked. She flipped a beauty pageant on its head with a single dance. The Oscar should’ve gone to the only kid who didn’t play for applause.

Screenshot from Little Miss Sunshine (2006)Fox Searchlight Pictures, Little Miss Sunshine (2006)

Advertisement

Linda Blair – The Exorcist

She levitated, swore like a sailor, spun her head, and still made you feel sorry for her. Linda Blair was 14 and possessed every scene. The role made headlines and sparked protests; however, it's exactly what made her performance unforgettable. 

Screenshot from The Exorcist (1973)Warner Bros. Pictures, The Exorcist (1973)

Advertisement

Ivana Baquero – Pan’s Labyrinth

Her audition was so powerful that Guillermo del Toro adjusted the script for Pan’s Labyrinth, which called for an older actress. That gamble paid off—her performance remains the film’s emotional anchor, and the movie is considered one of the greatest modern fantasies ever made.

Screenshot from Pan’s Labyrinth (2006)Warner Bros. Pictures, Pan’s Labyrinth (2006)

Advertisement

Henry Thomas – ET The Extra-Terrestrial

When Steven Spielberg met Henry Thomas, the boy improvised a tearful audition so convincing that the director instantly hired him. That emotional honesty powered ET, especially in the farewell scene. The film went on to break box-office records in the 1980s.

Screenshot from E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)Universal Pictures, E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)

Advertisement

Drew Barrymore – ET The Extra-Terrestrial

At just six, she brought instinct and energy that couldn’t be taught. Drew Barrymore came from a famous acting family, but held her own in every scene. Spielberg often kept the camera rolling, trusting her unscripted reactions more than the script itself.

Screenshot from E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)Universal Pictures, E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)

Advertisement

Christian Bale – Empire Of The Sun

Long before Batman, Christian Bale held down a Spielberg war epic at 13. His transformation from spoiled schoolboy to survivor felt lived-in, not acted. Still, he was snubbed completely. Years later, Spielberg still calls Bale’s performance one of the best he’s ever directed.

Screenshot from Empire of the Sun (1987)Warner Bros. Pictures, Empire of the Sun (1987)

Advertisement

Saoirse Ronan – Atonement

Saoirse Ronan’s breakout role came in Atonement at just 13. Playing Briony, she exposed the destructive power of a child’s imagination. Her accusatory testimony in the movie didn’t just affect one character. It became the hinge on which the entire wartime drama turns.

Screenshot from Atonement (2007)Focus Features, Atonement (2007)

Advertisement

River Phoenix – Stand By Me

There’s a moment in Stand by Me when River Phoenix breaks down while talking about a stolen milk money envelope. It lasts seconds. But that scene alone deserved gold for its perfection. He was 15, acting like a kid trying not to cry in front of friends.

Screenshot from Stand By Me (1986)Columbia Pictures, Stand By Me (1986)

Advertisement

Asa Butterfield – The Boy In The Striped Pajamas

Asa Butterfield was only 10 when he played Bruno, a boy who befriends another child through a concentration camp fence. The final scene, with Bruno’s confusion turning to terror, demanded recognition the Oscars never gave. His innocent questions drove the story toward its devastating conclusion. 

Screenshot from The Boy in the Striped Pajamas (2008)Miramax Films, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas (2008)

Advertisement

Natalie Portman – Leon: The Professional

Playing Mathilda wasn’t about being tough—it was about being broken without ever saying it out loud. Natalie Portman pulled that off at 12. She made a contract killer look fragile and a child look dangerous. Although the Academy ignored her, no one else did.

Screenshot from Léon: The Professional (1994)Columbia Pictures, Leon: The Professional (1994)

Advertisement

Freddie Highmore – Finding Neverland

Freddie Highmore wasn’t intimidated by acting beside Johnny Depp and Kate Winslet. At 12, he gave Peter a fragile strength that powered the film’s emotion. The park bench scene where he finally breaks down felt so real that Depp cried once the camera stopped rolling.

Screenshot from Finding Neverland (2004)Miramax Films, Finding Neverland (2004)

Advertisement

Isabelle Fuhrman – Orphan

The Academy never acknowledged Isabelle Fuhrman’s work in Orphan, even though she carried that psychological horror on her back at just 12. She performed her own stunt work, stayed in character between takes, and adjusted her own voice pitch to hide her age—the twist only worked because she did.

Screenshot from Orphan (2009)Warner Bros. Pictures, Orphan (2009)

Advertisement

Sophie Nelisse – The Book Thief

Playing Liesel required mastering both accent and tone. And Nelisse did both while showing the courage of a child growing into rebellion. Director Brian Percival praised her focus, noting she never broke character during long war sequences. The Academy, however, chose not to recognize her.

Screenshot from The Book Thief (2013)20th Century Fox, The Book Thief (2013)

Advertisement

Natalie Wood – Miracle On 34th Street

Oscar voters overlooked Natalie Wood, despite her leading the Christmas classic at just eight years old. She played a child who doubted everything—even Santa. To preserve that disbelief, the crew kept Edmund Gwenn (the actor playing Santa) away from her even between scenes. Funny enough, the method worked.

Screenshot from Miracle on 34th Street (1947)20th Century Fox, Miracle on 34th Street (1947

Advertisement

Roman Griffin Davis – Jojo Rabbit

Roman Griffin Davis did not receive any recognition for Jojo Rabbit, though he carried the satire on his 12-year-old shoulders. His mix of naivety and desperation kept the movie human. And his breakdown when discovering the shoes hanging in the square remains the movie’s most gutting, Oscar-worthy moment. 

Screenshot from Jojo Rabbit (2019)Searchlight Pictures, Jojo Rabbit (2019)

Advertisement

Millicent Simmonds – A Quiet Place

Deaf in real life, Millicent brought authenticity to A Quiet Place by shaping how the family’s communication was portrayed. Krasinski credited her for designing moments that made the film credible. Her emotional breakdown after discovering her father’s sacrifice carried the movie’s final act without a word spoken.

Screenshot from A Quiet Place (2018)Paramount Pictures, A Quiet Place (2018)

Advertisement

Chloe Grace Moretz – Let Me In

No nomination recognized Chloe Grace Moretz’s work in Let Me In. At 12, she played Abby with quiet restraint, torn between friendship and monstrous survival. Her underwater rescue scene—bodies thrashing while she stays eerily calm—showed she could control terror and tenderness at once.

Screenshot from Let Me In (2010)Relativity Media, Let Me In (2010)

Advertisement

Macaulay Culkin – Home Alone

Macaulay Culkin wasn’t nominated for an Oscar for carrying a $476 million global hit at age 10. He also improvised several lines, including “Guys, I’m eating junk and watching rubbish!” That kind of improvisation is rare for actors at that age. 

 Screenshot from Home Alone (1990)20th Century Fox, Home Alone (1990)

Advertisement

Jeremy Blackman Magnolia

When Magnolia was in Oscar conversations, Jeremy Blackman’s name never came up. He played Stanley, a boy crushed under game-show pressure, with unnerving quiet. His final line, begging adults to treat him kindly, resonated louder than many of the film’s award-nominated performances.

Screenshot from Magnolia (1999)New Line Cinema, Magnolia (1999)

Advertisement

Elle Fanning – Phoebe In Wonderland

Phoebe’s struggles in Phoebe in Wonderland demanded restraint, and Fanning delivered it at ten. What stood out was her ability to shift from defiance to fragility without exaggeration. In the rehearsal scene, she improvised lines that were so natural the director decided to keep them.

Screenshot from Phoebe in Wonderland (2008)THINKFilm, Phoebe in Wonderland (2008)

Advertisement

Lina Leandersson – Let The Right One In

The pool scene remains unforgettable. Leandersson’s Eli doesn’t appear until the water turns red, yet her calm presence dominates it. She wasn’t nominated, though the film’s reputation as one of the greatest horrors of the century rests on her performance.

Screenshot from Let the Right One In (2008)Magnolia Pictures, Let the Right One In (2008)

Advertisement

Onata Aprile – What Maisie Knew

For What Maisie Knew, Onata Aprile didn’t rehearse key scenes beforehand. The director kept her in the dark about the story’s custody conflict to preserve her natural reactions. Her performance had to bridge every adult conflict, and she did it without a single explanatory monologue.

Screenshot from What Maisie Knew (2013)Millennium Entertainment, What Maisie Knew (2013)

Advertisement

Lewis MacDougall – A Monster Calls

Lewis had lost his mother months before filming, and that real grief fueled his role as Conor, a boy facing his own parent’s death. Director J A Bayona said that he actually had to cut filming days short because the young actor’s raw emotion left crews shaken. However, no Oscar nod followed.

Screenshot from A Monster Calls (2016)Focus Features, A Monster Calls (2016)

Advertisement

Julian Dennison – Hunt For The Wilderpeople

Ricky’s haikus, delivered with deadpan wit, were Julian Dennison’s invention. Waititi encouraged him to improvise, and much of it stayed in the script. That looseness made Ricky unforgettable, not a caricature. Oscar voters praised the screenplay but gave no attention to the child actor driving it.

Screenshot from Hunt for the Wilderpeople (2016)Fox Searchlight Pictures, Hunt for the Wilderpeople (2016)

Advertisement

Dakota Fanning – I Am Sam

The courtroom scenes in I Am Sam weren’t simplified for Dakota Fanning. At seven, she handled legal dialogue and improvised responses to Sean Penn’s shifting performance. The director said she memorized both parts of every scene in case lines changed during filming.

Screenshot from I Am Sam (2001)New Line Cinema, I Am Sam (2001)

Advertisement

Jamie Bell – Billy Elliot

Jamie Bell wasn’t nominated for Billy Elliot, even though his role demanded both physical training and emotional range. Bell was trained in multiple dance styles for months before filming. The final scene was performed entirely by him and was shot without music to capture every breath and movement in real time.

Screenshot from Billy Elliot (2000)Universal Pictures, Billy Elliot (2000)

Advertisement

Keisha Castle-Hughes – Whale Rider

Oscar history was made when Keisha Castle-Hughes became the youngest Best Actress nominee. Her nomination itself was historic. She trained in Maori customs before filming, giving authenticity to Pai’s journey. Her tearful plea during the whale-riding sequence became the film’s emblem. 

Screenshot from Whale Rider (2002)Buena Vista International, Whale Rider (2002)

Advertisement

Max Records – Where The Wild Things Are

Max Records gave weight to a film built on imagination. Working at 12 without formal training, he turned Where the Wild Things Are into a story about real childhood pain. His portrayal of a boy lashing out, then searching for connection, kept the fantasy grounded.

Screenshot from Where the Wild Things Are (2009)Warner Bros. Pictures, Where the Wild Things Are (2009)

Advertisement

Elijah Wood – Radio Flyer

Before The Lord of the Rings, Elijah Wood showed award-worthy talent in Radio Flyer. At 11, he played Mikey, protecting his brother from abuse. His emotional plea for safety was devastating. Reviews predicted awards, but his name never appeared when nominations were announced.

Screenshot from Radio Flyer (1992)Columbia Pictures, Radio Flyer (1992)

Advertisement

Thomas Turgoose This Is England

Shaun is 12, alone, and easy to manipulate. Thomas Turgoose gave him an authenticity that didn’t feel performed because, at the time, he had never acted before. Despite delivering the most honest performance in the film, Turgoose was completely ignored by the Academy.

Screenshot from This Is England (2006)Optimum Releasing, This Is England (2006)

Advertisement

Sean Nelson – Fresh

Most of Fresh played through long silences and subtle expressions. Sean Nelson, just 13, carried a lead role with no acting experience and little rehearsal. His final scene opposite Samuel L Jackson held tension with no music, no cuts—just a child outmaneuvering every adult in the film.

Screenshot from Fresh (1994)Miramax, Fresh (1994)

Advertisement

Kodi Smit-McPhee – The Road

Playing a child raised in post-apocalyptic ruins, Kodi Smit-McPhee had no stunt double for emotionally intense scenes. He filmed the moment he begs to feed a stranger in one take, without direction between setups. He was about 13 and was central to the plot. 

Screenshot from The RoadThe Weinstein Company, The Road (2009)

Advertisement

Jared Gilman – Moonrise Kingdom

Most of Moonrise Kingdom hinged on how Sam was played. Jared Gilman, 13, had never acted before, yet handled the blocking, timing, and deadpan tone across full-length takes. In fact, Wes Anderson cast him because he read with no expression—and told him not to change a thing.

Screenshot from Moonrise Kingdom (2012)Focus Features, Moonrise Kingdom (2012)

Advertisement

Georgie Henley – The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe

The entire emotional arc of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe hinged on Lucy’s reactions. Georgie Henley, just 9, acted opposite green screens and costumed stand-ins while maintaining full emotional clarity. Plus, her first on-screen scene—meeting Mr Tumnus—was filmed with no second take.

Screenshot from The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)Walt Disney Pictures, The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)

Advertisement

Zain Al Rafeea – Capernaum

Filmed without rehearsal, the courtroom scene in Capernaum was shot in one long take. Zain Al Rafeea, a Syrian refugee with no acting background, improvised most of his dialogue. His final speech to the judge stunned critics and drove the film’s international acclaim.

Screenshot from Capernaum (2018)Neon, Capernaum (2018)

Advertisement

Alex Hibbert – Moonlight

Hibbert’s performance introduced audiences to Chiron’s life. He had never acted before, yet the director cast him after one audition. The swimming lesson scene was filmed with minimal direction, relying on his instincts. Though Moonlight won Best Picture, Hibbert’s contribution was left unacknowledged.

Screenshot from Moonlight (2016)A24, Moonlight (2016)

Advertisement

Sunny Pawar – Lion

At six, Sunny Pawar carried Lion’s first half. The Oscars ignored him, though his performance was central to the film’s global success. Pawar filmed in multiple languages, learning lines phonetically. Garth Davis praised his instincts, saying he never needed more than two takes.

Screenshot from Lion (2016)The Weinstein Company, Lion (2016)

Advertisement

Ana Torrent – The Spirit Of The Beehive

Few actors carry symbolic films, let alone at age six. Ana Torrent gave The Spirit of the Beehive its eerie stillness without knowing the political subtext. Her long take with the imagined monster was filmed without direction—just raw reaction—anchoring one of Spain’s most acclaimed films.

Screenshot from The Spirit of the Beehive (1973)Janus Films, The Spirit of the Beehive (1973)

Advertisement

READ MORE

Internalfb Image
May 12, 2025 Alex Summers

20 Best Religious Films (Ranked According To IMDb)

Movies tackle faith in countless ways. IMDb users have rated these religious films highest among spiritual cinema. Some directors approach divinity with reverence. Others ask tough questions. The best films? Well, they do both.
Bloopers Internal
February 16, 2024 Eul Basa

10 Famous Movie Bloopers That Made The Final Cut

Sometimes, bloopers end up being unanticipated treasures that actually improve a film and add an element of realness to an otherwise cut-and-dry story.
Oscars Internal
February 20, 2024 Sammy Tran

10 Most Awkward Moments At The Oscars

The Oscars may be Hollywood's biggest night, but even it is not immune to shocking moments.
Internalfb Image
December 21, 2024 Alex Summers

All of these movies are from 1994, making it arguably the best year in cinema history.

1994 was an excellent year for film. A range of outstanding theatrical creations, varying genres, splendid characters, interesting plotlines; it had it all. So, which movies made it great? Let's see.
Hollywood’s 11 Biggest Financial Disasters of 2025
July 28, 2025 Marlon Wright

2025's Biggest Box Off Flops, So Far

Hollywood accountants probably needed therapy this year. Studios watched their biggest bets crumble faster than stale popcorn. Famous names, huge budgets, and dreams of franchise gold all meant nothing when audiences simply stayed home.
Internalfb Image
December 20, 2024 Alex Summers

Movies That Made Everyone Cry In The 90s

"Dad, wake up... we gotta go home," young Simba pleads, his voice breaking. If that iconic scene from The Lion King still brings tears to your eyes decades later, you're not alone. Here are 90s films that'll make you cry HARD.